Originally posted by SScollector
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Haarnadel SS (toter Kopf
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by SScollector View PostI'm sure that it would be quite common for people to dig out original SS tuxedo badges from the battlefields these days, as the Germans always wanted to look very sharp and flashy while they were fighting the war.
Chris
Comment
-
Originally posted by G23 View PostIhave no doubts that this is the original, since i personally found it, its authenticity will only be proved by a highly qualified expertise
Ian
- 3 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ian Hulley View Post
Try Kai Winkler ... I'm quite sure you consider him to have 'highly qualified expertise'. He certainly has LOTS of experience on these tuxedo badges.
Ian
post-77043-0-59554600-1374434025.jpg
Comment
-
Hi,
1) i forwarded the pictures to the owner of an original, i will update the topic if i get any comment from him.
2) What are the odds to find a pre-war tuxedo badge in the mud of Ukrain ?
In my opinion they are very slim, but again, i would love to have the opinions of owners of original tuxedo badges.
3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden...of_(philosophy)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(law)
The burden of proof is always on the person who brings a claim in a dispute.
You have to prove that your badge is original, we do not have to prove that it is fake (but we can help on that though).
4) Many ground dug fake items were already debunked on the WAF,
Many websites from various countries are "promoting" fake items that are said to be "originals" because they were ground dug.
I have various examples for the Germanische Leistungsrune. The goal is of course to find "believers" that will buy those items.
5) @ olle : can we please focus on the tuxedo badge of G23 ?
To post blurry pictures of previously discussed dubious tuxedo badges will not help the discussion at all.
There are already a lot of similar topics on the WAF about the various recent "dangerous" fakes.
See You
Vince
Comment
-
Originally posted by SScollector View PostThanks for the additional photos, but my opinion remains the same. The markings on the back of the skull should be "M1/21" (matching the markings on the banners), but the "1" is almost completely void on the skull. The RZM marks are very sloppy, compaired to an original. This has all of the typical signs of a casting, imo, regardless of it being ground dug.
Chris
Comment
-
In my opinion, the badge in question is not a Winkler reproduction. The skull details, (front and back), are actually better on some of the cast fakes that were made prior to the Winkler fakes. The markings and lettering in the motto, however, are more crisp on the Winkler repros. So, each type of fake has better details in some areas than the other, neither being close to 100% accurate.
Here is my badge for the records. Sorry, no reverse photo.
ChrisAttached Files
Comment
-
Originally posted by SScollector View PostI'm sure that it would be quite common for people to dig out original SS tuxedo badges from the battlefields these days, as the Germans always wanted to look very sharp and flashy while they were fighting the war.
Chris
- 1 like
Comment
-
Originally posted by Robert H View PostPlesse send Detail photo of the skull head of the ground dug badge
here you are
Comment
Users Viewing this Thread
Collapse
There is currently 1 user online. 0 members and 1 guests.
Most users ever online was 8,717 at 11:48 PM on 01-11-2024.
Comment