Gielsmilitaria

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Panzer Pioneer Black Wrapper II

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by djpool View Post
    My (obviously poor)attempt at sarcasm.
    No, excellent use of sarcasm; I was a little slow on the uptake.

    Comment


      While the number stamps have been changed up, I believe the letter stamps are the same. Whats unmistakeable is the similarity on how the items were actually stamped.

      Originally posted by OSS View Post
      I suspect these two examples were made by the same hand.
      Attached Files

      Comment


        Originally posted by djpool View Post
        Another common wrap with black lining for sale.
        Jim,
        This is the stamp n°2 shown previously in #83, the n°1 same source.

        Comment


          Originally posted by Richard P View Post
          Phil,

          A note on collar piping. Keep in mind that the Panzer Police piped their wraps right up until the end of the war. It is almost impossible to find one that does not have the collar piped in photos. I have dozens and dozens of panzer photos with piped collars and many are later war wraps and HG wraps. Perhaps they are all done after the fact, and not from the factory.

          Richard

          Yes I agree. I think that the Police regulations on these wraps and every other police uniform item were pretty independent from what the Army was doing. The police material in my limited experience with it seems to be be a better quality and for much later in the war that what I see with Army.I also think that while most agree that collar piping being factory applied on Army wraps ended for the contract wraps around 1939, it continued to be worn until the end of the war and was also often added by officers and NCO on both contract wraps that they owned (purchased) and had made long after 1939...

          One thing that tends to get overlooked is that it can be very difficult to spot additions and alterations made by expert tailors to uniforms during the period (and I guess that could apply to post war modifications as well). meaning that the easy and simple way to effect an addition or modification was not always followed. I have seen collars opened up along the edge seam to add piping in what I believe were wartime upgrades.....but you can also find piping added by sewing the "edge selvage" along the underside edge of the collar.....both can look very neat when done correctly....but obvously the first technique is much more labor intensive.

          Comment


            Originally posted by djpool View Post
            While the number stamps have been changed up, I believe the letter stamps are the same. Whats unmistakeable is the similarity on how the items were actually stamped.
            Interesting Jim.

            A family concern no doubt, cousins perhaps? Operating in different cities (Posen & Essen). Catering to special wraparound orders from uncommon, small units.

            Nothing difficult to accept about that; or so the proponents will have us believe.

            And the dealer is, may I ask?

            B. N. Singer
            PS, forgive my sarcasm Mr. Pic.

            Comment


              Originally posted by B. N. Singer View Post
              Interesting Jim.


              And the dealer is, may I ask?

              B. N. Singer
              https://www.history-shop.de/katalog/...nes_77147.html

              Kay Winkler - who had caused some trouble lately

              Comment


                Originally posted by B. N. Singer View Post
                Interesting Jim.

                A family concern no doubt, cousins perhaps? Operating in different cities (Posen & Essen). Catering to special wraparound orders from uncommon, small units.

                Nothing difficult to accept about that; or so the proponents will have us believe.

                And the dealer is, may I ask?

                B. N. Singer
                PS, forgive my sarcasm Mr. Pic.
                I would not be surprised if these two wrappers were not made in the same room on the same machine by the same "artist".

                Comment


                  Originally posted by djpool View Post
                  While the number stamps have been changed up, I believe the letter stamps are the same. Whats unmistakeable is the similarity on how the items were actually stamped.
                  Nice bit of CSI Mr. Pool.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by OSS View Post
                    I would not be surprised if these two wrappers were not made in the same room on the same machine by the same "artist".
                    But PLEASE do NOT say on a "Singer" sewing machine!!!

                    Best to you Sir.

                    B. N.

                    Comment


                      Many German uniforms were made on Singer brand sewing machines, a result of what is now called "the global economy".

                      Comment


                        I think Bryon was thinking of not using the brand name as a possessive instead of as a proper noun as intended.

                        Bob Hritz ( an unfortunate grammar geek)
                        In the land of the blind, the one eyed man is king.

                        Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can muffle the sound.

                        Comment


                          Originally posted by OSS View Post
                          Many German uniforms were made on Singer brand sewing machines, a result of what is now called "the global economy".
                          Yes, of course; but I was referring in a "deflected" way to a post made by the owner of this Pz pio example, directed at yours truly, which has long since been deleted.

                          Oh yes Bob, that too. Thank you Sir.

                          B. N.

                          Comment


                            Stamps often are the first clue to give a fake away. I have to hope and right now believe that there are always other characteristics to to reveal them as well, but I guess if a fake is perfect then it is sort of moot as to what to look for!

                            I mention stampings because too much information can get the faker in trouble quickly with a sharp collector....such as a date that does not fit with the item's properties or a depot or maker that does not fit with each other ....or any number things (sizes way incorrect) all have been seen before....so I wonder if they are leaving these a vague as they think that they can get away with?

                            I say the above because the stamps are really the easiest thing to get right with a little work and knowledge.

                            Comment


                              Excellent illustration Jim, the thread has become interesting and educational again!
                              Esse Quam Videri

                              Comment


                                Yes its the GD Wohlgemuth and Pz PI Wohlgemuth stamp. Jim

                                Originally posted by derka View Post
                                Jim,
                                This is the stamp n°2 shown previously in #83, the n°1 same source.

                                Comment

                                Users Viewing this Thread

                                Collapse

                                There are currently 17 users online. 0 members and 17 guests.

                                Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                                Working...
                                X