MilitariaPlaza

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

SS Julcandle and document: how rare

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    It's Michael's thread, he's counting, not me, I just made the quick reference as an idea to help, ie stop double counts

    Comment


      Originally posted by Dmv View Post
      @ Steve, you know that there are boxed candles on this Czech page right?

      http://julleuchter.mypage.cz/menu/ob...im/julleuchter

      I don't know who ownes it, but if it's none of the 7 persons in your count you can probably count at least one more?
      Hello Dmv,
      I cant access your provided link.
      So...can not even peek at it.

      Probably best if everyone provides a photo from now on to stay eternally trapped on the WAF matrix limbo, or it wont be too helpful for our thread.

      Comment


        caveat emptor

        Lets be clear that I am not too comfortable with some of the candles shown.
        You can all tell that some really look fresher and retain the integrity of original form as if there has been no stress from 50 years of weather changes.
        Not saying I can PROVE anything is not kosher, and I can be a wrong as anyone else, BUT
        they look a bit too new, AND I have been warned that there are now a few fakes out there...including the box.
        So, just because they are shown here, is not meaning I am 100 percent comfortable with all of them.

        Personally I am more comfortable with the candles that look and feel really old and have that (perhaps hard to replicate) 50 year natural destabilization of the color and greasy like aged sheen of certain candles.

        As usual, I think a bit of extremely healthy suspicion is called for.

        Comment


          Might sound daft but give them a sniff I don't know how long it would take the volatile substances that give the beeswax honey smell to out gas but I find it hard to believe that an old candle would smell.

          I put my nose to my JulKerze and I can't smell anything! I then tried a modern candle and it smells like honey. So, no science or fact here but if a Jul-kerze has some aroma all I can say is I'd certainly be suspicious.

          Comment


            Yours doesn´t smell?

            Must be a reproduction then.

            Comment


              Originally posted by Thorsten B. View Post
              Yours doesn´t smell?

              Must be a reproduction then.
              OK you're poking fun but it makes sense, think about it, to smell beeswax there has to be something given off by the wax and how long can beeswax out gas and give off a gaseous form chemical compound that the olfactory receptors in your nose can detect? I don't know how long but its not going to be forever and I doubt very much that it can do it for 68 years, at some point it will have surely stabilised and stopped out-gassing.

              Comment


                Saw you post Steve about beeswax candles giving off an aroma? The modern day beeswax candles are advertised as 99 and 44/100 % pure. Just like Ivory. No additives whatsoever. I would suppose those made for the Julleuchter would have similar manufacturing characteristics.

                Comment


                  Originally posted by JoeW View Post
                  Saw you post Steve about beeswax candles giving off an aroma? The modern day beeswax candles are advertised as 99 and 44/100 % pure. Just like Ivory. No additives whatsoever. I would suppose those made for the Julleuchter would have similar manufacturing characteristics.
                  Hi Joe,

                  I use 100% beeswax candles with no aroma additives, they give off the natural honey type smell so something out-gasses for a while, I'm just saying I doubt any old ones would smell as they have would have reached a more stable state.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Michael Fay View Post
                    Hello Dmv,
                    I cant access your provided link.
                    So...can not even peek at it.

                    Probably best if everyone provides a photo from now on to stay eternally trapped on the WAF matrix limbo, or it wont be too helpful for our thread.
                    Micheal, for me the link still works?
                    http://julleuchter.mypage.cz/menu/ob...im/julleuchter
                    Just found them while browsing on the net, so don't know the (Czech?) owner...

                    But here are the photo's
                    Attached Files

                    Comment


                      .
                      Attached Files

                      Comment


                        Micheal, there is also a loose julcandle document for sale by Sebastian (WAF name Ojoneso) now, so you can also count that one (doc. only)
                        http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=559866

                        Comment


                          I've seen a boxed candle with document at a museum so that's another one.

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Dmv View Post
                            Micheal, for me the link still works?
                            http://julleuchter.mypage.cz/menu/ob...im/julleuchter
                            Just found them while browsing on the net, so don't know the (Czech?) owner...

                            But here are the photo's
                            Thanks for the images Dmv,
                            I still cant access that link .My computer keeps saying the page has changed.

                            Anyway, interesting photos.
                            First ..obviously wrong wrapping paper for the candle. Hope they make mention of that, if not then trust is diminishing.

                            Also I am suspicious of the address pasted on the box . I cant read the whole thing (that which is not ripped off) but the heading is easily readable and I have missgivings.
                            Can the address posted on the box be blown up bigger without loosing definition?

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Dmv View Post
                              Micheal, there is also a loose julcandle document for sale by Sebastian (WAF name Ojoneso) now, so you can also count that one (doc. only)
                              http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=559866
                              Already knew about that one Ojoneso posted it in this thread a long time ago! LOL
                              So I believe that doc was counted.

                              As you can see we have to be careful not to count anything twice.
                              Last edited by Michael Fay; 12-19-2011, 04:53 PM.

                              Comment


                                Originally posted by Minnesinger View Post
                                I've seen a boxed candle with document at a museum so that's another one.
                                Minnesinger,
                                Do you remember the name of the museum?
                                it would help to tie down this one for counting purposes.

                                As any one who has read this whole thread, you will see it is getting hard to not start adding up already noted documents and candles/boxes as a new addition to the count.

                                Comment

                                Users Viewing this Thread

                                Collapse

                                There is currently 0 user online. 0 members and 0 guests.

                                Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                                Working...
                                X