Thank you for that: clearly, there is new analysis out there (and I must confess to not - yet - having read No Holding Back by Brian Reid - but it's on order) that requires all of this be revisited. The layout of the fields has changed, as has the fauna and the like, but the topography remains broadly the same. As such, one key issue would be to definitively identify the firing positions of individual tanks, and Ekins' has - to date - been rather well documented. From it, one can clearly see the location where Wittmann's tank is believed to have been destroyed, but it would indeed have been a difficult shot, albeit against the relatively weaker side armor...
Thanks also for giving me a reason to revisit that area, which I will now have to do again. Ekins is credited with knocking out four Tigers that charged on the eastern side of the N179 towards Gaumesnil from his position near Les Jardinets, and three other Tigers charged on the west side of the road. Wittmann's was on the east side of the road when it was destroyed, and many will recall that his remains - and the exact position of his tank when destroyed - didn't really come to light until 1982. It is also my understanding that the Sherbrooke Fusiliers' original daily log book was destroyed and only rewritten ex-post-facto, based on the memories of those involved.
There was a LOT of armor fighting that day: indeed, the whole Delle de la Roque sector was heavily fought over, and the burned out remains of both sides' tanks littered the landscape after the battle. And of course, at the time, Allied armor commanders and gunners didn't really care who commanded what enemy tank, only that they knocked them out...
So, again, my thanks for pointing me towards new review and analysis of this engagement. Fortunately, we can now generally all agree which specific Tiger Wittmann used at VB, and which one he died in...
Thanks also for giving me a reason to revisit that area, which I will now have to do again. Ekins is credited with knocking out four Tigers that charged on the eastern side of the N179 towards Gaumesnil from his position near Les Jardinets, and three other Tigers charged on the west side of the road. Wittmann's was on the east side of the road when it was destroyed, and many will recall that his remains - and the exact position of his tank when destroyed - didn't really come to light until 1982. It is also my understanding that the Sherbrooke Fusiliers' original daily log book was destroyed and only rewritten ex-post-facto, based on the memories of those involved.
There was a LOT of armor fighting that day: indeed, the whole Delle de la Roque sector was heavily fought over, and the burned out remains of both sides' tanks littered the landscape after the battle. And of course, at the time, Allied armor commanders and gunners didn't really care who commanded what enemy tank, only that they knocked them out...
So, again, my thanks for pointing me towards new review and analysis of this engagement. Fortunately, we can now generally all agree which specific Tiger Wittmann used at VB, and which one he died in...
Originally posted by recceboy
View Post
Comment