Funny business?! Two different preliminary KC document to the same guy!

[kaiserwilhelm2]

Hi Guys,

this morning I was looking at a preliminary KC document which I like(d). I decided to check with our moderator Simon to get a second opinion. He pointed out that a a similar document to the same guy had been sold some time ago on Manions (including two other award documents and a couple of pics). Good call Simon! The fact there are to preliminary KC documents made out to the same guy seems a bit fishy. Can anyone tell which is good and which is bad or maybe both are no good? I am sorry for the quality of the second pic but unfortunately that is all I have.

Cheers, Willem

[InfanterieSammler]

Hi Willem,

I checked my files and found this scan of the first document. I'm not sure where the file came from, but I am comfortable with this document. Attached is a similar example which I sold earlier in the year.

Regards,
John

[Simon O.]

Here's the Manions sale from 2007

http://www.manions.com/priceguide/re...spx~id~5842021

I think this is a classic case of boosting an original grouping, the DKiG doc he i think is also suspect but whoever did it clearly either had or had a picture of the original.


I agree with John that the one Willem is looking at is the original.