catch
..
..
-
-
Hi Tony,
I******180;ve looked long and hard at your badge.
It certainly is******180;nt a textbook BSW AG/RO thats for sure.
Both wreath and eagle look more like Imme products to me. The hardware on the reverse is more in keeping with BSW though. Certainly the hinge and hook would fit. The rivets also do not look so bad.
I******180;m not to sure about originality at this moment. There are things I like but also some red flags. I******180;m not so keen on the lack of hand finishing although BSW was******180;nt great on that anyway.
Can you get a large closeup of the MM up?
SkipLOOKING FOR ALL ITEMS CONNECTED TO HERBERT SCHOB.Comment
-
Tony,
That is one that I would be concerned about. The devil is in the details, and IMHO, the devil is lurking in this one. The catch is ala BSW style, but just lacks the workmanship (shaping) I'd expect. The reverse looks 'soft'. The rivets are domed, not flattened, and the beak isn't hooked. Unless others here are aware of variations, it's not a typical example, as Skip also pointed out.
And others have presented their issues too. I'd wait for a similar badge, if I was you, but one with a 'higher approval rating'.
Regards,
Mark
Last edited by mmiller; 12-24-2005, 09:07 AM."You can check out any time you like ..... But you can never leave....."Comment
-
Lorenzo,
What happened to that image? I am honored that you used my BSW as a reference, but where did all the black background (that Seba wanted!!!) go? I recognized it as mine when I saw the reverse image with the doghair on the scanner platform.
MM"You can check out any time you like ..... But you can never leave....."Comment
-
Ship and Mark,
Thanks for your opinions. Skip here is the maker mark you requested. If anyone else would like to make a comment please do.
Thanks
TonyComment
-
Hi Tony. In the continuing spirit of "agreement" that is permeating the Forum this Holiday Season...I agree with Skip and Mark.
Compare your badge to this known fake BSW Pilot badge on the left and you will see similarities in material and hinge/pin construction. Note the small crimp in both pins near the hinge. Also see the next posting for a comparison of the marks.Visit my Badge Collection: http://lbmilitaria.homestead.com/home.htmlComment
-
See this comparison of maker marks. The top two marks are from authentic BSW ROG and Pilot Badges. The second two marks of from the fake BSW Pilot badge shown in the previous post, and the mark from your ROG.
Notice how the two lower marks have shorter "stems" and the letters are smaller and are placed closer within the center of the shamrock leaves.
I believe your ROG came from the same maker as the fake Pilot badge.Visit my Badge Collection: http://lbmilitaria.homestead.com/home.htmlComment
-
Good close up work Lorenzo,
And in the makermark....... edited out here, so as to not tip the fakers of their mistake..........
"Who would ever notice that?", the fakers thought!
MarkLast edited by mmiller; 12-24-2005, 05:19 PM."You can check out any time you like ..... But you can never leave....."Comment
-
Mark,
sure you want to leave that infomation up??
Its one of the things about a BSW mark I keep quiet.
Tony, sorry but your badge is clearly a copy of an Imme AG/RO and with a bogus BSW mark and characteristics. Pretty good!!!
Nice comparisons Lorenzo.
SkipLOOKING FOR ALL ITEMS CONNECTED TO HERBERT SCHOB.Comment
-
Skip,
On one hand yes, just to screw the fakers. But on the other hand, do I want to help them redo their mistake
.
Well, I'll take it down. If anyone wants to know, just PM me.
Mark"You can check out any time you like ..... But you can never leave....."Comment
-
IMO a good move Mark.
Don´t want to make it to easy do we
SkipLOOKING FOR ALL ITEMS CONNECTED TO HERBERT SCHOB.Comment
Comment