Coastal Artillery badge HA for Review

[ROND]

Gentlemen,

I bought this badge from M&T Militaria but the badge seem different to me when comparing with the site pics.

The point is, although this difference, this badge seems ok to me but i would like a second point of view from you guys.

Thanks for the attention.

https://imageshack.com/i/p4a3h56Ej

https://imageshack.com/i/exK5Rlxtj

https://imageshack.com/i/hl5FhYGdj

[Tom Yanacek]

Not for me!

Hello,

I'm not liking it. In my opinion it is a fake. The finish looks wrong and I am suspicious of the base metal. The detail looks weak to me. I also do not like the catch boss. There are other things wrong with it as well. Can you supply us with some measurements of the badge?

Best regards,
Tom

Here is an original (left) compared with your badge (right).

[Tom Yanacek]

reverse compare:

[ROND]

Hello,

I'm not liking it. In my opinion it is a fake. The finish looks wrong and I am suspicious of the base metal. The detail looks weak to me. I also do not like the catch boss. There are other things wrong with it as well. Can you supply us with some measurements of the badge?

Best regards,
Tom

Here is an original (left) compared with your badge (right).

Hello Tom!

Thanks a lot for your oppinion!

I'm not at home in that moment but as soon as possible i will provide the measurements.

The best.

[John R.]

uploaded

[John R.]

IMO, this is a fake. The hinge is wrong as is the main pin.

John

[Norm F]

Hi Guys,

Yes, it's the Staegemeir "Type 1" fake. Both types of Staegemeir are discussed here:
http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=510644

Best regards,
---Norm

[BubbaZ]

it's the Staegemeir "Type 1" fake.

I agree.
Cheers,
Hubert

[ROND]

Well, thanks a lot for the response gentlemen!

As i said, i saw a good badge in the site and he sent me a different badge.

Lucky that i stayed in the guarantee period yet!

Thanks again for all answers here.