Wow Schwelch, you have done with IABs what Eddie has done with Pabs, very impressive
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Non-Zinc IAB showcase
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by schwelch View PostHello Rob,
here are my examples:
I will begin with a silver Daisy 1 attributed to S&H, too. The difference to the examples of Graeme is the small plate under the hinge.
BR
Sven
Hi Sven
The variant you show does not actually have a plate under the hinge, the hinge is one piece folded sheet metal.
ATTRIBUTED BADGES - Just a quick note Sven, to say that there are quite a lot of collectors that do not fully accept some of the connections being made to some of the makers. Many of the makers do not have 100% proof.
Great to see the nice badges posted
regards
Graeme
Comment
-
Hi Graeme,
your are right about the plate under the hinge. Sorry I just had a look on the pictures and thought that there's a plate :-)
Furthermore you are absolutly right about the maker attribution of the badges. I know that there is not a proof for everything. This was the reason I wrote "attributed" because I thought this means that the badges are considered to be made by this maker, but there's no final proof for it.
BR
Sven
Comment
-
Originally posted by Graeme View PostATTRIBUTED BADGES - Just a quick note Sven, to say that there are quite a lot of collectors that do not fully accept some of the connections being made to some of the makers. Many of the makers do not have 100% proof.
So i have to show two Daisy 1 IABs.
At first the Bronze
Comment
-
Here's a steel bronze by S.H.u.Co. Has a tougher feel to it compared to it's silver counterparts...Last edited by Panzercracker; 02-16-2013, 11:45 AM.
Comment
-
Hi Guys
Some great looking examples here...
I did not see one of these, so here is mine.
BTW...The word "attribute" has many definitions when used as a verb or a noun. In this cause I would agree with Sven's use of the word.
Attribute: to consider as made by the one indicated, but in the absence of conclusive proof.
Such as; to attribute a painting to an artist.
Best Regards, fischer
Comment
-
Very nice badges guys, just lovely.
Surprised not to see a Wurster pop up yet, so here is mine.
Looking forward to the "Zinker" appreciation thread. That is where all the variations are....and where all the fun is IMO
TomAttached FilesIf it doesn't have a hinge and catch, I'm not interested......well, maybe a littleNew Book - The German Close Combat Clasp of World War II
[/SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]Available Now - tmdurante@gmail.com
Comment
-
Originally posted by schwelch View PostHi Graeme,
Furthermore you are absolutly right about the maker attribution of the badges. I know that there is not a proof for everything. This was the reason I wrote "attributed" because I thought this means that the badges are considered to be made by this maker, but there's no final proof for it.
BR
SvenOriginally posted by fischer View Post
BTW...The word "attribute" has many definitions when used as a verb or a noun. In this cause I would agree with Sven's use of the word.
Attribute: to consider as made by the one indicated, but in the absence of conclusive proof.
Such as; to attribute a painting to an artist.
Best Regards, fischer
Thanks for educating me, I did not realise that the actual definition of attribute was as you have explained, without final or conclusive proof.
I must start using that word more
I guess I was trying to say that there are some members that do not accept some of the connections, and would not use "attribute", as this would indicate that they considered a particular badge to be made by a specific maker.
Great badges posted, and thanks for the lesson.
regards
Graeme
Comment
-
Originally posted by fischer View PostHi Guys
Some great looking examples here...
I did not see one of these, so here is mine.
Best Regards, fischer
Not an IAB collector myself, but I was waiting to see a nice Hymmen, and this one is stunning, Don!
Best,
Greg
Comment
Users Viewing this Thread
Collapse
There is currently 1 user online. 0 members and 1 guests.
Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.
Comment