As much as I hate to see us discuss this issue on this great thread, some valid points are being made.
Bill is techincally correct in the content of only "pure" FJ items are discussed here. John and Jos are certainly correct (as I tend to agree) that both certain discussions get completely lost in the uniform section, and there is a very strong link with ground division, Luft tropical, etc to the Fallschirmtruppen. We do state this section is for "uniforms, headgear, insignia and field gear" of the FJs.
This could end up being quite the slippery slope however. Those items are also sometimes discussed elsewhere. In fact, almost everything here (documents, photos, FJ helmets, etc) can be discussed elsewhere, based on how we have the forum set up. We also say we discuss FJ badges here, but many, if not most, threads on FJ badges now take place in the Luft badge section. FJ Helmets get presented in the helmet section, yet it is the FJ collectors from here who go over and comment. Same goes for many Luft uniform/ insignia questions. Not a black and white issue here. People seem to place threads where they feel they will best get the answer to their question. Or to present items where they get the higlest level of interest. Something to ponder......
Bill is techincally correct in the content of only "pure" FJ items are discussed here. John and Jos are certainly correct (as I tend to agree) that both certain discussions get completely lost in the uniform section, and there is a very strong link with ground division, Luft tropical, etc to the Fallschirmtruppen. We do state this section is for "uniforms, headgear, insignia and field gear" of the FJs.
This could end up being quite the slippery slope however. Those items are also sometimes discussed elsewhere. In fact, almost everything here (documents, photos, FJ helmets, etc) can be discussed elsewhere, based on how we have the forum set up. We also say we discuss FJ badges here, but many, if not most, threads on FJ badges now take place in the Luft badge section. FJ Helmets get presented in the helmet section, yet it is the FJ collectors from here who go over and comment. Same goes for many Luft uniform/ insignia questions. Not a black and white issue here. People seem to place threads where they feel they will best get the answer to their question. Or to present items where they get the higlest level of interest. Something to ponder......
Comment