Karstwehr Soldbuch Pics are up!

[love4history]

Yes, bought it as a "probable" original (without garanties from seller). Expensive? Well, if you hope you're buying an original and it's a copy it's always too expensive eh? What makes you think it's a sammlerscopy?

[AJ]

Defently something wrong with it

Looks like page 1 have been aged with coffee.

AJ

[Ian Jewison]

As I mentioned I have seen them sold as such on ebay, militaria321 etc....
Re-enactors sometimes have them made up also.....there are plenty of site on the web that do it!
Either it is a collectors copy or a fake it doesn't matter in the end it is not original.

[love4history]

The guy in the photo looks familiar. I am sure it has been copied from a book but for the life of me I cannot think which one?

G

Hi,
Thanks for the input! If you would remember, definitely tell ok! That would of course give definite prove that it's not an original!
cheers

[Edward]

If you go to the link provided by Ian in post 14 of this thread it will explain things for you.

[JUNGCO]

Just a few mistakes. The time line for the issuing unit is wrong. The entries for the hospital stays are wrong. The length of service and activity and lack of different clothing issue, etc.

Jeff

[love4history]

Thanks for the input everybody!

[SiPo]

Hi,
Thanks for the input! If you would remember, definitely tell ok! That would of course give definite prove that it's not an original!
cheers

Hi,

Page 5, Waffen SS Uniforms & Insignia by Krawczyk & v Lukacs. Dont know if the photo is owned by Wade or Peter, but if it is, I'm sure they will not be happy to know it has been used for such a purpose.

G