EdelweissAntique

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Knight Crosses today

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by Sepp45 View Post
    RK preliminary award document to Oberst August Sorko
    Kommandeur Gebirgs-Jäger-Regiment 137 / 2.Gebirgs-Division
    Awarded on: June 20th, 1940
    One of the most terribly fakes i ever seen!

    Comment


      Originally posted by DDD777 View Post
      One of the most terribly fakes i ever seen!
      It's not a fake document; it comes from the book "Gebirgstruppe 'Die Ritterkeuzträger 1939-45' by biblio verlag.

      For more info, see this post: http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...4&postcount=13

      Comment


        Originally posted by DDD777 View Post
        One of the most terribly fakes i ever seen!
        Not fake...a very rare early-war example.

        Topic covered here a few years back.

        John

        Comment


          RK formal award document to Major der Reserve Fritz Feßmann
          Zugführer 1. / Panzeraufklärungs-Abteilung 7 / 4.Panzer-Division
          Presented on: October 27th, 1941

          (Photo credits to Andreas-Thies)
          Attached Files

          Comment


            Originally posted by Sepp45 View Post
            RK with Oak Leaves preliminary award documents to Hauptmann Hans Schalanda
            Flugzeugführer 8. / Sturzkampfgeschwader 1
            Presented on: April 3rd, 1943

            Staffelkapitän Schlachtgeschwader 1
            Presented on: October 24th, 1944
            Better photos of these documents, from the upcoming Andreas-Thies auction.
            Attached Files

            Comment


              RK preliminary award document to Generalmajor Max Lemke
              Kommandeur AufklAbt 17
              Presented on: October 18th, 1941

              (Photo credits to Andreas-Thies)
              Attached Files

              Comment


                RK preliminary award document to Unteroffizier Siegfried Köhler
                Meldestaffelführer I./PzGrenRgt 108
                Presented on: March 17th, 1945
                Attached Files

                Comment


                  RK awarded to Obergefreiter Max Friedrich
                  Stellvertretende Gruppenführer 3. / Grenadier-Regiment 558 / 331.Infanterie-Division
                  Awarded on: March 15th, 1944
                  Attached Files

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by John M. Donovan View Post
                    Not fake...a very rare early-war example.

                    Topic covered here a few years back.

                    John
                    Hmm, very interesting, thank you for the information, but anyway this documents are not legal. Similar situation with the awarding documents after the Ermachtigung from 22.04.45.

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by DDD777 View Post
                      Hmm, very interesting, thank you for the information, but anyway this documents are not legal. Similar situation with the awarding documents after the Ermachtigung from 22.04.45.
                      What another strange comment. Please explain to me how this is not a legal document.

                      This was a document issued by the Zentralabteilung of the Wehrmacht. How would this not be legal? If this was not legal, how do you think this soldier would have worn his KC throughout the war and not been arrested? This is not a soldier claiming postwar that he received the RK for which he has no proof.

                      John

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by John M. Donovan View Post
                        What another strange comment. Please explain to me how this is not a legal document.

                        This was a document issued by the Zentralabteilung of the Wehrmacht. How would this not be legal? If this was not legal, how do you think this soldier would have worn his KC throughout the war and not been arrested? This is not a soldier claiming postwar that he received the RK for which he has no proof.

                        John
                        I'm used to trust to historical documents and not to doubtful ,,discoveries" more than 70 years after the happening. Read the Reichsbesetztblatt from 01.09.39 Seite 1573. Everything else is amateur talent groups.

                        I'm big fan of DKiGs and RK EKs from festungs or U boots or awarding documents after 22.04.45 printed on toilet paper or napkins and i'm sure that this are originals and this guys deserve it but this documents are not legal, i hope you understand what i mean.

                        My base of 254 RK EK VBs tell me ex cathedra
                        that this type of documents from the middle of junу 1940 till the middle of December 1941 except the Zweischrift's must be signed from Brauchitsch in another place.

                        BR
                        Dobri

                        Comment


                          I will quote Simon, from the previous thread "The answer lies in the command structure used for the invasion of Norway and Denmark. Gruppe XXI under Nikolaus von Falkenhorst was placed directly under OKW and not through OKH. Furthermore, other officers who were awarded the RK on the same date have a note 'direkt verleihung' along with their award details. ie. awarded directly."

                          This explains why the document would not have been signed through the normal HPA channels, but rather a WH one. I agree that the majority of Army RK VB's signed during 1940-41 have a von Brauchitsch signature. I also have a database the spans several hundred original examples from which I've learned.

                          Your reference to RK awards made post 22.04.45 is not relevant to a 1940 dated RK VB issued by the WH Zentralabteilung. These are two entirely different things. We are talking about a soldier awarded an RK in 1940, received a VB, and wore his RK for the span of the war versus a soldier(s) who claims he received an RK in the last weeks of the war for which he has no VB or documentation.

                          Regards,
                          John

                          Regards,
                          John

                          Comment


                            RK formal award document to General der Artillerie Herbert Loch
                            Kommandeur 17.InfDiv
                            Presented on: June 16th, 1940

                            (Photo credits to Hermann-Historica)
                            Attached Files

                            Comment


                              RK formal award document to Oberleutnant Karl Helmer
                              Ordonnanzoffizier II./GebJägRgt 13
                              Presented on: November 5th, 1942

                              (Photo credits to Hermann-Historica)
                              Attached Files

                              Comment


                                Originally posted by Sepp45 View Post
                                RK formal and preliminary award documents to Kapitän zur See Friedrich Bonte
                                Führer der Zerstörer und Kampfgruppe
                                Presented on: October 17th, 1940
                                From Hermann-Historica, more photos of these documents.
                                Attached Files

                                Comment

                                Users Viewing this Thread

                                Collapse

                                There are currently 27 users online. 0 members and 27 guests.

                                Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                                Working...
                                X