ScapiniMilitaria

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Strange Merten U-boat story in German auction ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Strange Merten U-boat story in German auction ?

    Please look in www.hermann-historica.com

    There is No: 8957 = knights cross with oakleaves Merten !


    On the photos you can see:

    knights cross = as new - stamped 800 -
    oakleaves = worn (?) - stamped Silber L/50


    in Adrian Forman s book: Bravery Courage and Valour
    Page 275

    knights cross = worn - stamped 800
    oakleaves = worn - stamped 900 - 21


    2 different crosses 2 different oakleaves !

    2 different knights crosses with 2 different oakleaves both are belonged to Merten ?Or 2 knights crosses with oakleaves belonged to nobody !

    What is now correct ?
    Last edited by frankandfrank; 04-27-2011, 04:13 PM.

    #2
    Luck of the draw???
    Iam Uncle Sam
    That’s who Iam
    Been hiding out
    In a rock and roll band

    Comment


      #3
      It must not necessarily be the case that one is wrong. It could also be that both have been misinformed. The more important question is this: are both sets genuine articles of the Third Reich? I think the Formann set is and I can't see the pictures at HH.

      The only thing that can be done here is going by pure statistical values of award dates and oakleaves type. For me a L/50 set is far more believable for an award in Nov. 42 than a 21 set. But who knows, maybe he acquired a second set form the PKZ?

      It just shows the quagmire with named items ... Not the first time - will not be the last time.

      Dietrich
      B&D PUBLISHING
      Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

      Comment


        #4
        Ritterkreuz und Eichenlaub in herausragender Erhaltung, die Silberzarge des Ritterkreuzes gestempelt "800", geschwärzter Eisenkern, Hersteller Klein & Quenzer, Idar-Oberstein. 49 x 48,8 mm, 29,21 g. Das Eichenlaub rückseitig gestempelt "900" und "Silber L/50" für die Gebrüder Godet in Berlin, ca. 19,1 x 20,2 mm, 6,75 g. Mit ca. 46 cm langem, vernähtem und leicht getragenem Bandabschnitt im Originaletui, der Deckel leicht verzogen, unterseitig Etikett mit handschriftlicher Notiz Mertens "Original Ritterkreuz v. 13.6.1942 Nr. 1".
        Merten erhielt das Eichenlaub zum Ritterkreuz noch während seiner fünften und letzten Feindfahrt, die zugleich auch seine erfolgreichste war und vom 20.8. bis 6.12.1942 dauerte. Zwischen dem 12.9. und 6.11. versenkte er dabei sieben Dampfer, einen Tanker und ein Motorschiff mit insgesamt 56.330 BRT

        Comment


          #5
          A K&Q Knights Cross (maybe even with the three flaws...) awarded in 1942 reminds me extremely strong at Mr. Niemann ..... certainly another "first". For sure not his awarded cross, best case a second piece.

          The inscription by Mertens on the case (Original Knights Cross ... Number 1) could lead to the assumption that there was a number 2 (as an additional piece). I think that a switch with No. 2 (=K&Q) took place (or has the case the Klein & Quenzer inscription?).

          Case contents can be switched and an inscription like "This is original" is not always a guarantee that the content really is original - as convincing it might sound!
          B&D PUBLISHING
          Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

          Comment


            #6
            His normal knights cross - condition as new - was sold the last auction !

            Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939
            Das Ritterkreuz in herausragender Erhaltung mit Silberzarge, gestempelt "800", und geschwärztem Eisenkern, 49,1 x 48,8 mm. Der silberne Sprungring gestempelt "800" und "65" für Klein & Quenzer, Idar-Oberstein. Gesamtgewicht 31,21 g. Mit 74 cm langem, unkonfektioniertem Bandabschnitt im Originaletui, der Deckel leicht verzogen, unterseitig Etikett mit handschriftlicher Notiz Mertens "Original Ritterkreuz v. 13. Juni 1942".

            Comment


              #7
              This is really funny!

              Picture clearly shows NO K&Q.
              Attached Files
              B&D PUBLISHING
              Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

              Comment


                #8
                you are crazy guys, however I admire you

                Comment


                  #9
                  Perhaps more other news are coming !

                  Comment


                    #10
                    The only thing that I can add it that in 1942 no Knights Crosses marked with any PKZ number and for sure at the very last none with "65" were awarded. However, the situation in certain collector circles is such that the factual knowledge about such things is far lower than the amount of money in the purse.

                    This is how a certain Hamburg dealer "completed" missing crosses with his seemingly unlimited supply of Klein & Quenzer. When a lot of the owners realized this procedure, he bailed. This is such a similar case .... makes me think. No COA came with it?

                    Someone will buy it and it seems that at least he has a genuine RK with a genuine L/50 ...

                    Dietrich
                    B&D PUBLISHING
                    Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

                    Comment


                      #11
                      i wondered about the same, since Merten's knights cross in the auction is nearly brand new and it doesnt fit to the award date. I dont want say that it was not in Mertens possession, but as Dietrich showed he clearly wore a different (Juncker) KC.

                      Frank, is it possible to post a scan of the "Merten" cross in Foreman's book? I wonder if it is a Juncker.

                      many greetings.

                      Stefan


                      PS: I also wonder about the "Harlinghausen" Ritterkreuz. Harlinghausen also wore a Juncker RK, but the cross in the auction is a "late" S&L....

                      Greetings,
                      Stefan

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I guess as long as it has a COA from a respected dealer, it will just pass as what is is described as being. I get a kick out of all the 'provenanced' Knight's Crosses and groups that rely solely on a dealer's letter or COA.

                        Were they postmarked from; Fantasy Island?

                        Bob Hritz
                        In the land of the blind, the one eyed man is king.

                        Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can muffle the sound.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          The "Merten" cross in Forman's book is a micro 800 S&L. Also looks like new, nearly no damage to the paint on the obverse and reverse. And the "21' oaks don't fit the time frame either. This set also comes with a case, but no inscription like " This is my second cross. Honestly! Merten" is mentioned.

                          However, a S&L is far more believable than a K&Q. But the "21" isn't!
                          B&D PUBLISHING
                          Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Kapitan Merten

                            While I am not an expert on identifying crosses from pictures, I will provide you all with a picture of Kapitan Merten with his cased oakleaves and RK. I remember the cross being stamped 800, but I didn't really look at the ring to see if there were additional markings. There was just too much to see and not enough time!!! This picture was taken in his study circa 1988.
                            Attached Files

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Did he have two sets?

                              Dietrich
                              B&D PUBLISHING
                              Premium Books from Collectors for Collectors

                              Comment

                              Users Viewing this Thread

                              Collapse

                              There are currently 4 users online. 0 members and 4 guests.

                              Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                              Working...
                              X