German Cross Opinions please

[The Jackal]

Hi Guys,

For a frend collector I am posting these pics. Is it original and what is the value of it ?

Thx.

[Hank C.]

I would venture to say these pictures are far too small to make any determination.
Any chance of larger/clearer photos?

Hank

[mrg]

Hi have to say im no expert on these but from these shots it does not look good and does not seem to have the detail, and quality you would expect to see. Better pics are definately needed. All the best

[Dietrich Maerz]

For sure not an official piece.

Dietrich

[Peter Wiking]

I do not like this one.

1. The stardish should be made in two (2) layers. One in silver and one in black/dark grey. I can see only the silver stardish.
2. There is no red color under the wreath.

Sorry.
Peter

[The Jackal]

Some additional pictures. Not all to good but hopefully good enough! Thanks again !

[Peter Wiking]

Not genuine in my opinion.

Cheers.
Peter

[Larry L]

Cross posted here doesn't conform to any known original pre-45 manufactured piece.

L

[Okrach]

I say it is not an original piece - it reminds of the one I have once and it was a fake...

[The Jackal]

Thanks guys. My friend collector found the piece so had thoughts that it could be an original piece. Gues not....

[J G]

I don't like the look of that

[The Jackal]

Thanks guys. I told my friend that it is alsmost for certain an reproduction. If there are more opinions on it please let me know.

[Peter Wiking]

Thanks guys. I told my friend that it is alsmost for certain an reproduction. If there are more opinions on it please let me know.

Maybe you and your friend could do a search on the forum on this type of award? I am sure you will discover the problems with the piece in question.

Good luck.
Peter