side
-
-
Side by side with yoursComment
-
hi Dj
many thank for your replay
here is the back of one of mine...it lack of the metallic solder
the metal seems to be different..your seems to be alluminium...is it possible?
Last edited by Bob65; 01-27-2007, 05:39 AM.Comment
-
And here are the three differents sardsch ...the moste fake seems to be the mine..
See the rivers...mine and yours are similar..the 3d is completely different, seems to be more accurate
Last edited by Bob65; 01-27-2007, 05:39 AM.Comment
-
Hi all,
This is a pretty scarce little badge, not really known among many collectors either.
In my opinion (like the D******252;nkirchen shield) this belongs in the categorie campaign shields but never is recognized as such.
Anyway my judgement: as it is a fairly uncommon, unknown to many it is not the a badge that I would fake if I wanted to make a quick buck.... so I would not say they are fakes just yet.
We need more background information first as there is a big probablitiy that there were multiple companies with minor variances in manufacturing details explaining the differences shown here.
Best all images and details of these shields among us are collected in one thread and be examined and compared to make the (logical) theory as I think much original information has been lost.Comment
-
thanks for enlightening me on this award. one gets to the point where he feels confident in his knowledge of the topic and then is totally blown away. i love itComment
-
hi,
thank DJ. I would like to know if we can know what metal was used for it and what manufacturers, but i think it will be almost impossible to know it.
bobComment
-
Originally posted by Bob65 View Post
Hi Bob,
The one I own is aluminum. The other one posted appears to be brass.I'm not familiar with that version. I did another comparison of yours with mine to point out what appear to be differences. The letters on yours appear to be crowded together. JimComment
-
I also did a search for other shields Heres one Gordon Williamson posted before.
Gordon if you want me to remove it let me know.JimComment
-
Here are a few miscellaneous showing who they are attributed to.Comment
-
yep,
if you see the hooks for the needle, mine is different although from a geographical point of view the differenes between the two are minimal. Mines are identical.
One was bought from weitze one year ago, the other from milshop 4 weeks ago.
It is strange that boths identical come from two different seller.
The one from Wiliamson is similar to your.
If you are sure about the origin of your, i think that can be considered original. Mines not....Comment
-
Hi Bob,Originally posted by Bob65 View Post
I think Gordons and mine are identical. Thats really the only version I'm familiar with. Doesn't mean there weren't other manufacturers.
Mine came from a vet here in town along with the two 5th Mountain division cap badges shown below.WR JimComment
-
more images from the net....very interesting
in the link is other description http://www.axishistory.com/index.php?id=4511Last edited by Bob65; 01-29-2007, 02:33 PM.Comment
Comment