retailing godet

[Montgomery Burns]

well first of all here one can see the correct godet stamp used 1903 .
and the Koch & Bergfelt stamp

showing the retail habits of the time .

fore those who who wonder who made what ?


this evidence makes maker ek identification theory's standing on thin ice .

but interesting as new theory's can be made from here on .
or believes can be hardened .....

regards kay

[Montgomery Burns]

ps Koch & Bergfelt made wonderful cups .

[saschaw]

this evidence makes maker ek identification theory's standing on thin ice .

Could you please speak a bit more verbosely - which theories and why? Thanks!

[Montgomery Burns]

well ,

lets see ,,,

if , those jewellers had so little problem to buy from each other and (by )over stamping the maker marks .

who can say a ek 1870 marked wagner is a wagner ?
a godet a godet ?
also counting fore 1914.

already the mix up in 1870 frame's is pointed out , this explained it to me
http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=605977

maybe all the time there was no pure maker that kept to his own pure tool design

so easy to point out the so called retailers so far , but maybe you just had small producers/retailers and big time producers /retailers .

only one did it big scale,,,,, one did not .

until now some were wryly sure who where the makers and who not .
maybe that has to be reconfigured as there is no maker such as we saw it until now .

regards kay .


.

[Montgomery Burns]

example

just theoretically

as example

a year ago or so godet marked prinsen ek's turned up

strange mark and absolutely different in shape and design as what would be normally seen from Godet

maybe the where so different because
they where not ordered at Koch & berfeld , wagner , werner , or made by themselves (as Godet normaly would do )

but ordered somewhere else fore just a small number.

sabby ?

[Roglebk]

"a year ago or so godet marked prinsen ek's turned up

strange mark and absolutely different in shape and design as what would be normally seen from Godet"

The Godet Prinzen did not turn up a year ago, they been around for long.

The mark is not strange, nor is it a uncommon Godet mark as research has proven.

[Montgomery Burns]

I ask Don to delete this thread ,,,,













.

[Roglebk]

Please don't Kay. The theory is ok, only a bit far fetched.

[Montgomery Burns]

thank fore your nice words ,,

well sometimes evidence like this comes up ,,,


and sometimes the things picked up , sometimes not .


I think thinking out of the box is needed here.

because of self-inflicted collector romantic's surrounding the ek ,

the German jewellers are placed on a to high mountain .

forgetting that the jewellers of the time may not gave a romantic **** about the iron Crosses,
but where just in it fore the money and how much they could get fore it .

and business was just as wicked as these day's .

I hope you start looking fore other sign of my far fetched theory.
it may be throe

regards kay