SS embroidered collar tabs original ?

[Ajaxides]

Hello everyone,
I do not know what to think of this collar tab, thank you in advance to all those who will kindly give me their opinion!
Cheers
Jack

[coogan]

How can it be on a uniform and off at the same time ?

[Stossgruppe3]

How can it be on a uniform and off at the same time ?

Good point . . .
This has also been up for review not so long ago too
My opinion hasn't changed its a fake
Regards David

[Stossgruppe3]

Good point . . .
This has also been up for review not so long ago too
My opinion hasn't changed its a fake
Regards David

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=939453


As I said " This has also been up for review not so long ago "
So why have you started a new post ?
Regards David

[coogan]

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=939453


As I said " This has also been up for review not so long ago "
So why have you started a new post ?
Regards David

Perhaps this time it will be real ?

[Ajaxides]

How can it be on a uniform and off at the same time ?

It is simple, as there were serious doubts on the part of members who know the subject well, and to be absolutely sure, it was also necessary to see the reverse ; so I disconnected it. According to the first opinions, it would seem that it is a fake ; so no regrets to have.

[Ajaxides]

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=939453


As I said " This has also been up for review not so long ago "
So why have you started a new post ?
Regards David

Hi David, I preferred to put the two together so that there was no mistake. That's why I made a new post. If I'm wrong, please excuse me because I'm not very comfortable with computers ... In any case for your opinion, this collar tab is a fake. thank you for your opinion
Best regards
Jack

[Ajaxides]

Perhaps this time it will be real ?

Of course there is this risk, but what matters most to me is knowing for sure if this collar tab is genuine or a fake. This research is only a sentimental question; the financial value is irrelevant. But what do you think about this collar tab?
Best regards
Jack

[Bob Hritz]

I believe this collar tab is a post war copy.

Bob Hritz

[MM1985]

Clear Copy tab

[coogan]

Of course there is this risk, but what matters most to me is knowing for sure if this collar tab is genuine or a fake. This research is only a sentimental question; the financial value is irrelevant. But what do you think about this collar tab?
Best regards
Jack

I am not qualified at this point to give an informed opinion . I will defer to those more qualified in this thread who have already given their opinion. I was just pointing out it seemed odd the it was both off and on a uniform , and you explained why . Have a good day.

[Ajaxides]

The opinions are unanimous, this collar tab is therefore a fake, so it will be thrown into the fire; that one will not deceive anyone!
Thank you to all those who kindly gave their "informed opinion."
Best regards
Jack

[coogan]

I am using your misfortune to learn from , here is a side by side of yours and another recent one pronounced as good . I can see a difference in quality of stitching.

[Ajaxides]

I am using your misfortune to learn from , here is a side by side of yours and another recent one pronounced as good . I can see a difference in quality of stitching.

Thank you very much coogan for your post which actually allows to compare the two embroidered collar tabs. I think this is the best way to see the difference between real and fake. it would be really nice if this way of presenting is done as often as possible on the forum !
Best regards
Jack