Dot 44

[chahler]

Real one or Janke
Post for a friend

[Graham G]

Janke

[chahler]

Janke

Thank you !
Its early or late one ?

[ironcross13]

Is the material original? Is it sold are real?

[Scott A. Hess]

Photos are not really detailed nor close enough to know if its a Janke product, either way, its bad, and Janke is no longer considered any benchmark for good looking reproductions, Id look to ATF and SM wholesale..much better, if your looking for something closer to original.

[Scott A. Hess]

Is the material original? Is it sold are real?

NOT original material, not even close.

[ironcross13]

Dot 44

I though there was not much green colour in there and looked odd, but as I'm not a expert did not want to make a opinion.
This is my m-44 pea dot.
Lower pockets are field removed

[cbuehler]

Photos are not really detailed nor close enough to know if its a Janke product, either way, its bad, and Janke is no longer considered any benchmark for good looking reproductions, Id look to ATF and SM wholesale..much better, if your looking for something closer to original.

Agreed with this. SMW is a bit better than ATF, but not by much. Janke dot was the thing 20 years ago, but no longer.

CB

[Stossgruppe3]

Most if not all of Janke stuff only ever had two greens
The dots were considerably smaller too on a very dark brown herring-bone material
when bought from new. Constant washing gave it that awesome worn look whats now call been there .... look
Regards David

[Graham G]

No, its not SMW, or any other repro maker to my knowledge. janke, for most of its production, had all 5 greens, only very early ones had 4. most common 4 color ones are old SMW (which, in fact, do have 5, just a veerrry slight difference). Its janke. look at the shades of green used.

[erikjo]

Most if not all of Janke stuff only ever had two greens
The dots were considerably smaller too on a very dark brown herring-bone material
when bought from new. Constant washing gave it that awesome worn look whats now call been there .... look
Regards David

I see three greens on this one, maybe it's not a Janke? should also have better pics.

[Graham G]

to the OP: Post photos of the stamps inside. That's a surefire way to tell if janke construction or not (although, still 99.9% certain the fabric is Janke regardless)