SS Collar Tab original ?

[Hanhart]

Please tell me it's good or fake?

[Stossgruppe3]

It's not something I would be happy with ....
Regards
David

[Hanhart]

Ok, thank you

[sgstandard]

Tab

The shape is much more like an SA tab, but this SA rank never wore bi-color tab piping.

[jmcm]

my tab

This is one that I had and it was a vet pick up, I thought it was SA COLLAR TAB EARLY STURMMANN BERLIN

[sgstandard]

Tabs

My bad - I forgot that very early SA enlisted tabs were like this. After 1933, only SA OFFICERS had bi-color tab piping. Early SS enlisted tab piping was all white.
IMO, the first tab posted could be ok, but I'm not sure. Also IMO, the last tab posted IS original.

[Hanhart]

Thanks guys for your opinion