JULLEUCHTER Your opinion, if it possible, please

[Massimo F.]

I quoted you in full Antonio, no need to "read"
Anyhow this thread as Toten said has reached the end of the line so to speak

[booteen]

Really let's finish this thread
I did not want to offend or to teach someone
I do not understand why Antonio so aggressive...
I made only two julleuchters - you see them
are they fakes? are they sold? sold as originals? NO!
I would call it just a joke
I have not seen his book, I do not know anything about the classification of julleuchters... but I believe that any research book is very useful for the collectors

[Der_Stahlhelm]

Am I wrong or was it closed this thread yesterday???

[Totenhead]

Could we see some comparison photos please?

Sorry guys, I know this thread was meant to be closed, but just managed to take a few comparison pictures of the two together. Been really busy past few months with a car restoration

Here they are together, my original 6 dotter on the right, as you can see there are lots of differences, I do not think anyone has a reason to be concerned....
Happy Julfest !!

[rob NL]

Interesting thread!!

[H-U Rudel]

Time to remember

kind regards

Uli

[MFarbe68]

Great information, and greater to even to read the reaction of the experts. All around a great enjoyment, and lots of things to learn from all sides.

To see how easy it can be, also showed on the Hitlerjugend forum about a flag for the HJ that is made from start to end, and here as well surely all experts would say "original" and then when showed not, cry and find a reason why they are wrong, but at the same time right! (naturaly as they are the experts)

And great to see how such a person is handled !
When somethings can be obtained for free, yes, speak nice and give thanks.
When you look dumb, say unkind things and still try and make it look you are right!

It is not a surpise that the maker and poster no longer visits here for many years. Every one here could have learnt things they did not know, but when you read the reactions, it is clear how selfish some can be to keep up the good image, thinking only for themself, and not for the many others.

And have you seen the tree lights? My god, quality, not as the ones i paid for last year! I live and learn, and so should others to.

Be kind to each other, you never know when you will need something from each other. And i dont mean a free clay lights, i mean knowledge!