Runic opinions

[D Davies]

Hi I would appreciate some opinions on this runic tab on Barandywine miltaria's website
http://www.bwmilitaria.com/items/116...randywine.html
Cheers
Dave.

[Ian Hulley]

If it's a fake it would certainly fool me.

Ian

[D Davies]

Hi Ian
The reason i ask is recently a similar runic tab was posted here and deemed a fake but deemed original else were.
Cheers
Dave.

[PMan]

Tab

Looks fine.
Peter

[Ian Hulley]

Hi Ian
The reason i ask is recently a similar runic tab was posted here and deemed a fake but deemed original else were.
Cheers
Dave.

Ey up Dave, I was asked by PM to comment on that one too but I was less than 100% certain on that one, this one I would not hesitate more than usual. The other tab I like too but there's just a 1% of me that holds me back.

There was a TK tab a short time ago that also just left me cold yet I couldn't put my finger on why.

I'd rather be honest than help someone make a costly mistake by pretending to know something I don't.

Ian

[Totenhead]

I think i know the one Dave is referring to. This one looks better to me, the runes are more uniform and look better constructed, not sloppy like the other one

[D Davies]

Thanks Ian ,Peter and totenhead for your help and comments.I was suspiciouse because of the tab in the thraed i mentioned also the fact it has white cutting lines similar to foreign volunteer tabs.
Cheers
Dave.