My first tab

[jorkataaa85]

Gents,

I'm new in the hobby and would like to share with you my first tab.
What do you think of it?

http://s1303.beta.photobucket.com/us...tml?sort=3&o=4

Cheers

George

[jorkataaa85]

Could someone help me?
is it a good one?
Cheers

[Felix]

I am sorry but it is a reproduction.

//Felix

[C. Betz]

Tab

As Felix stated: "Reproduction". Runes construction is the first heads up. Very poorly executed. Buckram is another flag.

Use the Search function and key in "Runic Collar Tabs". Spend some time studying the examples .

Good luck.

Charles Betz

[jorkataaa85]

Its repro?|
Hm, looks like dachau tab to me...

[Woolgar]

I am sorry but it is a reproduction.

//Felix

Hi Felix

Please can you give some more detail as why you think it is fake

I have studied it with other tabs to no avail

Many thanks

Nick

[Woolgar]

Any more opinions on this tab please guys?

There is a divided camp on if it is original or not

Thank you

Nick

[mathiass]

To me, all but BeVo is difficult to spot.

[Felix]

Hi Felix

Please can you give some more detail as why you think it is fake

I have studied it with other tabs to no avail

Many thanks

Nick

Boot on the other side, why is it original? Have you ever seen another proved original rune tab like this? That is a very fair question to ask. To know SS insignias and to know your subject it recuires many hours of studies. 10, 20 or 50 is not enough. I have studied the subject fair enough and my verdict is firm. Have you compared the shape of the runes with originals? The thick stich lines on the reverse? The posted rune tab is a reproduction.
Where is the divided camp that you claim? Is that versus non knowledgeable and those with knowledge?
In that case the ones with knowledge wins.

Its a fake, over and out!

//Felix

[Woolgar]

Boot on the other side, why is it original? Have you ever seen another proved original rune tab like this? That is a very fair question to ask. To know SS insignias and to know your subject it recuires many hours of studies. 10, 20 or 50 is not enough. I have studied the subject fair enough and my verdict is firm. Have you compared the shape of the runes with originals? The thick stich lines on the reverse? The posted rune tab is a reproduction.
Where is the divided camp that you claim? Is that versus non knowledgeable and those with knowledge?
In that case the ones with knowledge wins.

Its a fake, over and out!

//Felix

Thanks Felix

That helps me learn and I will continue studying

Nick