Two SS Honor Rings opinions!

[jules61]

Hi Gents!
Are these two H.R. good or have some problems?
N°1.

202.jpg

202-2.jpg

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991643[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991644[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991647[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991648[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991649[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991650[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991652[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991653[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

Ring n°2

Ring N°2

18409_b.jpg

112_2.jpg

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991656[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991657[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991658[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991659[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

[ATTACH]1991662[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]1991663[/ATTACH]

[jules61]

Expertyse

The second one have also these expertyse!

112_9.jpg

[PHILBROWN]

i like the first very much, dont like the second,regardless of cert.

[Jeroen wo2]

Agree, the first one looks ok.

[sgstandard]

Tkr

Completely agree - 1st ring looks ok from photos - 2nd ring looks like a copy.

[addo]

Can anyone found any information on this "Knauz" ??? 1st ring!

21.12.1944

[Dedman]

Hi,
this is very interesting thread!
I personally have same strange feelings about 2nd ring too, but what does Don Boyle COA means? So it´s genuine item although collectors don´t like it? Or this COA belongs to another (previous) ring?