Opinions on these SS collar tabs

[neilnitro]

Hi, I have no idea on these, so could do with some help from some forum friends to tell me if they are any good or not . all help appreciate much appreciated.

[neilnitro]

and other one

they are a set

[neilnitro]

Heeelllllllppp

50 views and not one comment, please guys I really need some help on them, as I need to let the seller know tomorrow.

[rbno]

Black cloth looks looks OK on both, as does the buckram and general shape. Correct orientation of the runes. Cut lines are slightly uncommon on runic tabs, but were certainly used. There looks to be a little more black showing between the outlining of the runes and the main stitching, but not enough to cause me concern. (Could be shadow?) The blue secondary cloth on the runic is again odd, but this was certainly a correct construction technique for TR tabs (usually LW or SA, in my experience.)

Without having them in hand, I'd vote for them being good, but I do hope you get additional opinions, Hopefully one that confirms the runic as good.

Al

[johnm50]

They are fake

Have a look in the fake threads I am sure i have seen them there.
Best
John

[neilnitro]

moreopnions please

Hi,

I haven't found the thread yet, I could do with more opinions,as one bad and one leaning towards good.

some more input would be useful.

Thanks neil

[viva_giulio]

fakes too much perfect lines wrong embroiding