SS tab opinions requested

[Eddie]

Hi guys,is this tab have any chance ?

thanks in advance,

Eddie

[Eddie]

r

[Francesco]

That's a good one!

[Winkelman]

For the rare " Loose weave " runes on wool - type , I do not like the shape of these runes at all - too skinny & far apart ..
Please start to compare to >> http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=451357

Just the 2 cents from an eagre student , who stands to be corrected - but thinks they should look like this :

[Greg Domian]

I agree, they look like they are trying to be the loose weave pattern but actually too tight for my taste.

Greg

[Winkelman]

I also happened to have this one on file as a known REPRO .
Never one to interfere , I hope I am correct on this - since I still need an original one in good condition .. !

[Eddie]

Thank you guys,anymore opinions ?

[John T]

Eddie, I am leaning towards bad, let me dig out one that I have that is bad...it is trying to copy a limited style,

John

[John T]

Eddie-

Yes it is bad for sure, the one Winkelman posted is what it should look like..here is another bad one...look at the lines in the weave on Winkleman's example...

[John T]

detail-

[Eddie]

Thank you John,case closed than.

[Bob Hritz]

Posts 1 and 6 show the same collar tab.

Bob Hritz

[Winkelman]

That's a good one .. !
This very same tab must have been discussed before then - and dismissed as repro ..

[wisches]

That's a good one .. !
This very same tab must have been discussed before then - and dismissed as repro ..

No, its a bad one
but a good bad one!
wisches

[Bob Hritz]

Thi is an original that was brought back with this eagle. Sadly, poor storeage caused the dye to run. It is a pain to clean this up with bleach, on a toothpick, but it wiould work.

It is currently on the e-stand.

Bob Hritz