Need help: WSS Tabs

[Kuifje69]

Dear All,

Would you please geive me your opinion about these tabs?

Many thanks in advance

Rene

[Kuifje69]

2

[Kuifje69]

back

[CurtD]

I don't like them.

[Felix]

Not original in my opinion!

Sorry,

Felix

[willysproject]

Very Right! I concur with the previous posts: Bad...
I wouldn't buy them...

regards,
Gerd

[Kuifje69]

Gerd and others,

Thanks for your replies.

Rene

[Mark Holden]

CurtD, Gerd, Felix,

I am sure you chaps are correct in your assessment of the tabs but for the wider education of this Forum, more expansive reasons as to why they are wrong rather than one liners, will help us all. Why are they wrong- I genuinely wish to know.

Many thanks

Mark

[johannes post]

hallo rene are these the one from willem ?

regards johan

[Mr.Jerry D]

Ok, Assuming these are the supposed to be the RZM style in my opinion here's what wrong with these:
The backing material is wrong, it doesn't look like the buckram was treated with anything, the rank litzen is to wide and wrong style (also looks like it is positioned wrong) and the overall shape of the tabs isn't quite right.
the sewn borders to the runes are too thick and the runes aren't the right shape, and look too thick and too flat.

at least they spelled "SS" right...

[Mark Holden]

Jerry,

Thanks constructive and helpful, that's what I call an informed reply.

Many thanks

Mark

[Mark Holden]

CurtD,Felix,Gerd,

Care to elaborate as to why these are wrong?

thanks

Mark

[willysproject]

Hi,

Mr Jerry D has already mentioned my worries.

regards,
Gerd

CurtD,Felix,Gerd,

Care to elaborate as to why these are wrong?

thanks

Mark

[Sergey]

CurtD,Felix,Gerd,

Care to elaborate as to why these are wrong?

thanks

Mark

Hello Mark, Persanally I cant say anything by these photos. I am not sure is it wrong buckram or not, because the photo isn't clear, the same situation with embroidering, because foreshortening of the photo isn't good. I think we need the better images.

[Sergey]

If this tabs of the same sort then I'll pass. http://www.germanmilitaria.com/Waffe...os/S09354.html
But I am not sure that these tabs are the same.