"Germania" cyphers

[Ken N]

I like the boards but I am lost when it comes to cyphers. Does anybody have an opinion?
.
.

[Stive]

I think it 's a good cypher

[sutka]

I like it too

[Ken N]

I see a single cypher being offered by LUX militaria. Showing it here compared with mine. The LUX cypher has sharper edges and a more shallow impression of the inside letter details.

Are these both good cyphers? Or is one of them bad?
.

[rbno]

Here is a pair of original Germania cyphers for comparison.

Alen

[Stive]

The cipher offered on LUX militaria looks like a fake. Here for comparison another shoulder board with code G and scan from the book A.Mollo.

[Ken N]

Here is a pair of original Germania cyphers for comparison.

Alen

Well, I guess that answers that. Nothing beats comparison photos as a learning tool. Many thanks for the good news!