Eagles opinion please !

[Frederic H]

Please could you give your opinions on this .
Thanks

[Lenny W]

The first 2 look like repros

[WEISNER]

I agree with Lenny, IMO both cloth are bad. there is a nice Luftwaffe Officers eagle for sale right now on the e stand in the insignia section. have a look or do a search and you will see both are bad!
As for the third metal example? other members will hopefully chime in with an opinion. what are your thoughts Frederic?
Kevin

[Fred Green]

Greetings All,

I don't care for either of the cloth breast eagle. Reproductions IMHO. The cap eagle looks good to me but I don't collect political or civil.

Fred

[JasonA]

I need some perspective in these photos to reasonably tell. I have a difficult time judging much when they're this close up.

However, even from these zoomed shots, both bullion eagles look fake to me.

J-

[Frederic H]

Thanks for the opinions !