My heer dolch,,,is all ok? HÖLLER

[maximus999]

Yours opinion please...thx

[Schlange]

Unfortunately not.
These one is fake Heer Holler Generic B, from Spain.

Schlange

http://www.mojalbum.com/schlange88/albumi

[maximus999]

Oooo ****! :-(

[angler]

Post some better pictures of the MM and close up shots of main parts.

Before accepting the comments made.

The cross guard looks like a Herder to me

[fdodge]

I agree. Better photos, especially of maker mark, are needed before we can call this one good or bad.

Frank

[maximus999]

Here and thanks for the help:

[maximus999]

And original picture in Klaus Butschek Antiques:
http://www.butschek-antiques.com/Edg...r-HOELLER.html

[maximus999]

And original picture in Klaus Butschek Antiques:

http://www.butschek-antiques.com/Edg...r-HOELLER.html

[WW2-Collector]

Schlange may be correct - Can you show the blade tang please

[dr01]

The blade and scabbard are post war reproductions. All you have to do is count the number of stripes on the thermometer. Repro's have a lot less then originals..I have a bad feeling about the grip too. This typical yellow color is often seen on repro grips.
Danny

[Schlange]

New photos only confirm my assumptions.

Wardagger offers a good explanation:

http://www.wardaggers.com/German_Dag...roductions.htm


Schlange

http://www.mojalbum.com/schlange88/albumi

[fdodge]

I would agree that this one is not looking good.

[heers68]

Agreed.. one of the better fakes out there.. Kevin.

[Manalishi]

New photos only confirm my assumptions.

Wardagger offers a good explanation:

I have nothing to do with the site but you can get a 360 degree view of the dagger by rotating the mouse wheel. Now that is pretty cool.

[victorbaule]

Do not think it's a reproduction of Toledo Spanish, usually in these reproductions include the name Berlin, not of Solingen