Good Weimar and WWI Buckles?

[RobertE]

I would appreciate a review for originality on these buckles. Thanks in advance.

regards, Robert

[RobertE]

#2

[RobertE]

#3

[Ric Ferrari]

I would appreciate a review for originality on these buckles. Thanks in advance.

regards, Robert

Robert,

it's not my field, but I believe the one by #2 is bad .

Ric

[NortonI]

Robert,

it's not my field, but I believe the one by #2 is bad .

Ric

Ric, you can be sure, this one is bad.

Robert,
The first one looks good, but I know of fakes - just like these. I wouldn't take it.

The tird one is fine, but in a bad condition.

Cheers
Thomas

[aechols83]

Hi, Robert
I agree with what they guys have said here about the three buckles. Just to add that the 2nd Imperial Prussian army buckle is bad by way of the wrong catch as well as the crown design.

Best,
Adam

[RobertE]

Thanks for the help. If I'm understanding correctly, the first and third buckle are good, but the #2 buckle is a replica?

[Mac 66]

Thanks for the help. If I'm understanding correctly, the first and third buckle are good, but the #2 buckle is a replica?

Hi Robert, yes the 2nd buckle is a repro, 1st & 3rd are

[RobertE]

Thanks Mac!