Early HJ Members badge fake?

[Jtshafiz]

Came across a post on another forum stating the the badges made by alfred stubb berlin SW 19 are considered fake? Wanted to ask the members if this in fact a reproduction badge?



Thank you,
Jason S

[Jtshafiz]

Wanted to nudge this again....hope someone can give me some insight as to if this badge looks good or is a reproduction?

[jimmy72]

No good ! Construction details are not consistent with period production . There are a few other issues as well and the HJ Research forum would be the place to find those answers. Here are a couple pics of my repro badge , sorry crap pics , but look at the edge .. not good .

[Jtshafiz]

Thank you for letting me know!

-Jason S

[jimmy72]

No problem ! Lots of good period HJ Arbeiter badges out there . Good luck !