sa-tinnies

[Oleg]

Hello! Please, who know - what is it?
Who could receive this?

[Oleg]

2

[Erich B.]

Looks like a fantasy piece based on an HJ Leistungs runic badge.
Erich

[Roman (Russia)]

I like it.

[Erich B.]

That's good--it's definitely a fake, but if you like it, that's what's important.
Erich

I like it.

[Roman (Russia)]

Erich,
tell why don't you like this tinnie? - maybe because you never saw similar or because this tinnie not present in all four Manions books?
I see that detals of this tinnie is good but date - 1930 not very important year.
Several years ago I already saw a similar tinnie in an Internet network.

Regards,
Roman

[stuart c]

Roman, what makes you think its a Tinnie ?,scan through the "Tinnie War" thread, I dont think you will find one that is anything like this badge.

[Erich B.]

Hello Roman,
I don't like it because it's not made like a German badge, not marked like a German badge, the markings don't make sense, and it has no clear purpose--the wording on the front doesn't tell me anything. Is it supposed to date from 1930? Is it supposed to be for members of the SA who joined in 1930? That coupled with the incorrect markings on the reverse tell me it's a fantasy piece.
I don't disagree that it's attractive, but IMO it's made well past 1945.
Erich

[Patrick W]

Check out the serial number, if there were 34000 more of these I'm sure one of us would think it good. Love that 922 silver mark and cast in hinge

[Roman (Russia)]

Check out the serial number, if there were 34000 more of these I'm sure one of us would think it good. Love that 922 silver mark and cast in hinge

Yes you right - if there were 34000 more of these then another people must be seen this badge. 922 - i think it's not silver mark because i suppose it's not silver badge.