Nurnberg & HJ Potsdam badges

[nd164th]

Here are some badges I got in, a 1929 Nurnberg and 2 1932 HJ Potsdam badges. How do they look.

[ErichS]

Well, the 29 RPT badge is a fake for sure.

[nigel2003]

?

could do with better pics,but from what i can see,all 3 are fakes.

[Gregorio Torres]

IMHO the Potsdam badge in the midle its a good one. Text book shample.
Could you tell us, Nigel, what wrong do you found on this item?

[nd164th]

info

any other opinions welcome

[nigel2003]

IMHO the Potsdam badge in the midle its a good one. Text book shample.
Could you tell us, Nigel, what wrong do you found on this item?

it would be nice to see a better photo of the bronze potsdam badge,i would only go for the one with the (H) in the dots.i cant see one on this bronze one,this is my opinion.

[Gregorio Torres]

You can be sure. The bronze one is original.

[sjl]

Don't have any trouble with either Potsdam badge. First picture's angle makes the silver look smaller, but 2nd one shows it is the right size.

[stuart a.]

same here both potsdam look fine bar for the dodgy pics

[nd164th]

badges

was hard to get the right angle with them leaning to one side, so looks like both potsdams are good and the 1929 Nurnberg is bad

[nd164th]

Potsdam badges

so both Potsdam badges good?

[ErichS]

was hard to get the right angle with them leaning to one side, so looks like both potsdams are good and the 1929 Nurnberg is bad

[nd164th]

1929 Nurnberg

And the 1929 Nurnberg is definatly bad?

[ErichS]

and the 1929 nurnberg is definatly bad?

yes!!!

[nd164th]

thank you

Thanky ou