Opinions on two SA Sport Badges

[Ron Weinand]

SA Sport's Badges

IMO both badges are good. The main problem with the Redo badge is that someone has cleaned (and polished) this piece so that the orginal frosting and dull silver finish has been damaged and somewhat changed.
Ron Weinand

[klr]

Hello Ron I jumped on this thread instead of starting a thread because the # on the gold badges were so close Same maker but a different back. Do you like the one I posted? Thanks Kirby

[Ron Weinand]

Bronze SA Sport's Badges

The SA Sport's Badges shown in this thread are Bronze, not Gold. The serial number is far too high to be a gold badge and in the wrong position from the ones that were true gold that I have encountered.
Ron Weinand

[klr]

Thanks Kirby