Gold Sports Badge opinion

[Tony]

Gentlemen,

I'd like to get some opinions on this Gold Sports Badge. What do you think?

Thanks,
Tony
<!-- / message --><!-- attachments -->

[Tony]

reverse

[Tony]

catch

[Ron Weinand]

I believe the badge is good, but the finish is not.
Ron Weinand
Weinand Militaria

[Christopher G.]

There seems to be pitting all over the front of this badge which makes me think it is a fake because the finish is not missing on these parts where the pitting is. I am going to go with "fake" on this one but these are not at all my area of expertise so I could could be wrong.

EDIT: Well I guess I dont know too much about the originality of the badge but it have the same opinion about the finish as Ron.

Regards,
Chris G.

[Wim Vangossum]

Am I wrong if I have the impression that I mis lack of detail in this badge? It just look not fine enough to me.

Regards, Theo

[Tony]

Thanks Ron, Chris, and Theo for your comments.

I think whatever the finish is on the badge has deluted the sharpness in the badges lettering. I'm posting the silver version of this maker, let me know what you think of this one compared to the gold one.

Tony

[Tony]

rev

[Tony]

catch

[Ron Weinand]

I believe this is a good silver by Redo.
Ron Weinand
Weinand Militaria

[williwo]

The silver badge looks good. The golden not.

[Tony]

Thank you Ron and Williwo

[Roman (Russia)]

Agree with Williwo. Type of gold badge's catch is not typical for Redo.

[PatAvitas]

Here is another of the silver "FUHPUNG" SA sports badges. I mentioned in another recent post on this type as I recently acquired one as well. Here is the other thread with the debate on this type of original variant (in my humble opinion) http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...hlight=fuhpung

Hope this lends some more info to this badge,
Pat

[GraveDigga]

both are original - the second is a fine silver but the first is "golden" repainted after repared the catch

GG