Any thoughts on this HJ Tinnie

[ravrick]

Hi,
is this a good one?
cheers,
Rick

[RonR]

This one is a bit different...
...

[ravrick]

Cheers, so the one I've shown is a fake?
Rick

[Volksturmer]

No idea if fake, but compared to Ron’s the detail is a bit less sharp. Could be age. Compare the back of the Eagle head and neck to Ron’s. And compare the needle arrangement.?
Just IMO

[Volksturmer]

Back of head and neck on the two look different.

[Wood]

Unusual fastening, but I could live with it, remember there was more than one maker for most badges.
Pete

[Volksturmer]

Pete,
good point. Looks legit, I wouldn’t throw it out of my collection either, unless someone else knows something I don’t.

John