ss tinnie opinions

[castle]

Is this a good tinnie or a fake. im not sure about it.

[KC1]

Don't see this tinnie that often but I do like this one. Need further inputs from those more knowledgeable about SS Tinnies

[mametz]

Looks good to me, and quite rare as well.

[Mike TM]

Not, sure about this piece, shouldn't the front be in two tones, like this one in the photo?

regards
Mike

[Volksturmer]

No expert - not close,
But maybe the first one was cleaned?

[castle]

i found out it is a fake..

[Glory-Didi]

weitze has a good one for sale

[mametz]

i found out it is a fake..

Fooled me great comparison picture
Mametz

[DanCz]

Would certainly have had this old boy fooled too - - - many thanks for your contributions. I have very little in the way of SS material in my collection of almost 50 years in the amassing for the simple reason i cannot effectively distinguish right from wrong !! Cloth, in particular, seems to me a complete minefield !!

[castle]

this is proof you really need to do your homework on these medals badges and tinnies especially ss items. fakes can be hard to identify..