2 SA Sports badges, any good?

[Jerek]

Hello,
I recently acquired two SA sports badges, one in bronze and one in silver. Both bear the same makers mark and text. I'd love some comments on these two badges, as these are not my normal collecting field and I'm not really sure about them being real. If any more pictures are needed I'd be glad to post some more.

Thanks in advance,

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...RRdEtRbnhWcFlR

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...RRdEtRbnhWcFlR

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...RRdEtRbnhWcFlR

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...RRdEtRbnhWcFlR

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...RRdEtRbnhWcFlR

[Edelweisse]

In my limited knowledge....I don't like them....the pin and catch assemblies are off. I have approx. 20 SA Sports Badges ...many by REDO and not have catches & pins like yours. There are other SMEs that will comment on these.

[bodes]

In my limited knowledge....I don't like them....the pin and catch assemblies are off. I have approx. 20 SA Sports Badges ...many by REDO and not have catches & pins like yours. There are other SMEs that will comment on these.

The catch and pin are different to mine as well....I also believe what I see is poor detail on the backside where the outline of the sword meets the swastika.....Better photos would be nice....Bodes