SA Officer Tunic opinions please..

[Pink]

Opinions greatly appreciated...rank identified as Obergrupenfuhrer (?)...thoughts greatly appreciated..,,the Coburg is a repro..

about 8 photos top come
Cheers
FS

[Pink]

photo 2

Opinions greatly appreciated...rank identified as Obergrupenfuhrer (?)...thoughts greatly appreciated..,,the Coburg is a repro..

about 8 photos top come
Cheers
FS

2nd set pics

[Pink]

#3

2nd set pics

3rd set pics

[Pink]

4th pics

3rd set pics

4th set pics

[Pink]

rank clarification

the rank, I believe should be Oberfuhrer...?
the Arrow on the left arm appears oversized and s/b black arrow, not gray(?)

any assistance will be appreciated...

[notton]

Nice tunic but I think an Oberführer should have an private purchase tunic and not an issued one .

[GAMS1]

+1
Nick

[Pink]

negatives..?

+1
Nick

Nick, is that a no for authenticity, or...?

Thanks..

[Pink]

thoughts about the 'Arrow"...

Nick, is that a no for authenticity, or...?

Thanks..

Also, is the arrow correct..? Thought they were smaller and black...?

[Bob Coleman]

This is an other ranks reworked tunic. It is not officer quality material. One does not often see belt ramps on officer tunics. The ty rune is a poor copy of the genuine article.

[Erich B.]

I agree with Bob. The collar tabs with metal devices were not often used after the early 30s and were no longer produced--leaders were supposed to upgrade to bullion tabs. The boards are the later type (post 39) so there is even less likelihood that a high leader would wear this combination. Add to that the fantasy Tyr rune and the fact that it's an 'enlisted' rough wool tunic--IMO this is a put together.
Erich

[Pink]

Thank to all..

I agree with Bob. The collar tabs with metal devices were not often used after the early 30s and were no longer produced--leaders were supposed to upgrade to bullion tabs. The boards are the later type (post 39) so there is even less likelihood that a high leader would wear this combination. Add to that the fantasy Tyr rune and the fact that it's an 'enlisted' rough wool tunic--IMO this is a put together.
Erich

Much appreciate everyone's candid input. Enough info to warrant not going forward with the purchase...another reason to appreciate having such expertise on this forum..

Cheers everyone...
Floyd