SA-Treffen Badge

[718design]

Hi Guys
What are your thoughts on this badge ?
All comments are very much appreciated.

Thanks
Jan

131.jpg

133.jpg

[ErichS]

I don't care for it for a couple reasons, the leaves look like they don't turn up like on originals as well as no clear leaf on the top left near the eagle wing. Also, I see no RZM marking on the reverse. Just not one that I would want.

[ErichS]

I forgot to mention that the leaves on the edges look wrong as well. It just looks rough without the normal detailing you like to see.

[ETN]

I forgot to mention that the leaves on the edges look wrong as well. It just looks rough without the normal detailing you like to see.

I agree, also it looks like it may be cast.

[Gregorio Torres]

I don´t like this one, but it isn´t the tipical fake. I had seen this issue never before. Could you tell us what kind of hardware is made please?

[David North]

Perhaps it is somewhat unfair to submit a photo merge of an original Assmann against the badge presented, however it is a stark reminder about clear detail, irrespective as to whom the manufacturer was.

In my opinion, the badge shown is a cast fake and the "pocking" around the oak leaf wreath is possibly a supporting indicator.

If this badge and as I think is a fake, then I guarantee that over a period of time it will "improve" to include the colour of the composite metal.

Good to see the S over the R !!

Regards,

David