NSFK Badges - Opinions

[KC1]

Appreciate the discussion from my previous post so I thought I might solicite your information on the following two badges.

First up is the 1939 Reichswettkampfe Alpenzielflug. Avery handsome badge with beautiful blue and yellow enamel. Look forward to your opinions.

[KC1]

2

[KC1]

3

[KC1]

4

[KC1]

5

[KC1]

The second badge is the 1938 NSFK Reichsflugwettbewerb Kustennachtflug. ANother very handsome badge with blue and green enamel and a striking NSFK emblem.

[KC1]

2a

[KC1]

3a

[KC1]

4a

[KC1]

Bringing back to top for comments.

[KC1]

No response from any forum members on thoughts about these 2 badges???

[Duzig]

Hello
I think the consensus on these badges is mixed. I have read different things on different forums but regarding the kustennachtflug I beleive(correct me someone if I am wrong) that these badges are considered fantasy or bogus. I have heard some say that the way to tell original vs repro is the detail on the face of icarus...although others have said many of these badges were put together post war using original parts. There was someone on the forum who posted original NSFK badges, neither i believe of one's you show but I can't remember his name. If I remember correctly he received them directly from someone who participated in NSFK events. If you do a search on the forum I believe you will come across some queries regarding them. I will search also and see if I can give you links with more info about them. Sorry I can't give you any other info at the moment. I will see if I have some more definate info on my hard drive with other forum posts.
regards
Duzig(Bill)

[Scott C.]

I think Bill pretty much summed it up on these pins/badges. I have one of each and was told they were repros years ago...