SA Sports Badge question

[George Stimson]

Is there a consensus in the community whether SA Sports Badges marked with an all-capitalized "W.REDO" are good, bad, or indifferent?
Here's the reverse of the badge in question.

[George Stimson]

The obverse.

[peterm]

Hi George !

"W. REDO Saarlautern" is a well known maker of SA-Sports-badges. Your badge seems to be ok, but I'm not sure about the "silver". Looks a little bit strange, but maybe this is due to the pic itself.

Kind regards,

Peter

[Jamz]

The badge looks good. I would say motto indifferent. IMHO John

[George Stimson]

Thank you, gents! Does anybody else have an opinion?

[Nigel N]

bought one with all capitals from detlev, so if its good enough for him!! must say though, on this example, the lettering seems a little crude.