Autographed pictures of Boelcke and Immelmann for Review

[Sirius]

This is my first post in this forum, so before I start, hi to everyone.

I would be very grateful if you could have a look at the signatures in the attached autographed pictures of Boelcke and Immelmann.

Do you believe the signatures to be authentic?

Many thanks in advance,

Sirius

[VtwinVince]

Welcome to the forum. I don't like either of them, the Boelcke looks nothing like what I've seen, and the Immelmann appears to lack continuity.

[Sirius]

Hi VtwinVince,

Many thanks for your feedback!

Any other forum members willing to share their opinion on the authenticity of the signatures?

I purchased this item (a framed set with the shown autographed pictures) some time ago, and would like to be sure before I discuss the issue with the dealer.

Thanks again,

Sirius

[Jelle M.]

100% reproduction… not even close actually.

[Sirius]

Wow, what a disappointment!

I appreciate your reply, Nightstalker!

The dealer in question is considered to be reputable. I wonder why they would tarnish their reputation selling a reproduction that, compared to the usual high-end expensive items they offer, didn't bring in such a large amount of money after all.

Sad,

Sirius

[VtwinVince]

I've been collecting autographs since 1984, and the amount of fakery out there is worse than ever.There are many reputable dealers lacking knowledge who are peddling this junk, so do lots of research before buying.

[Sirius]

Dear VtwinVince and Nightstalker,

Thank you both for your comments and advice.

I'm a mere aviation enthusiast who got tempted into purchasing a memento of these early pioneers.

I'll talk to the dealer to see what he has to say about this item.

With lots of appreciation for your help,

Sirius