E-stand album opinions

[Simon O.]

What do you guys think?

The shooting photo is very well known indeed.


http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=791281


http://listverse.com/2012/12/07/ten-...hotos-of-wwii/

[Wolfsblut]

well known fake!

[štajerc]

really fake ?

[chrischa]

Added reprint or reproduced photo to sex the album up.

[chrischa]

Also, I'm not sure the W-SS photo fits with the RAD album.

I'm not implying the seller is attempting to sell dishonestly.

[štajerc]

It is not printed, but you guys know more that I and I I believe you.
I got this album in a big lot with photos, books and othar paper.
Moderator please remove the ad.
Thanks!

[frankandfrank]

The famous SS shooting photo was a fake by the Stalin propaganda !! Not a real photo !

[chrischa]

The famous SS shooting photo was a fake by the Stalin propaganda !! Not a real photo !

Hello.

Can you give any more information that the photo in question is a propoganda staged photo?
Cheers,
Chris.

[Mil-Archive]

I saw that earlier, I think that photo is called 'The Last Jew in Vinitsa'. It seems to be a half decent print but given the profile of the picture it'd have to be very suspect to begin wtih imo.


http://rarehistoricalphotos.com/last-jew-vinnitsa-1941/

[Manalishi]

I saw that earlier, I think that photo is called 'The Last Jew in Vinitsa'. It seems to be a half decent print but given the profile of the picture it'd have to be very suspect to begin wtih imo.


http://rarehistoricalphotos.com/last-jew-vinnitsa-1941/

Unless I missed it, there's nothing in that article to suggest that the execution was staged.

[Mil-Archive]

Unless I missed it, there's nothing in that article to suggest that the execution was staged.

I don't recall saying it was staged. I said given the profile of the picture - I'd be suspect of any print of that image being original.

[Volksgrenadier 44]

My first thought when viewing the thread on the estand yesterday was that I too would be suspect of any copy of that photo,there is a large blown up size version of it in the newly revamped Impy War museam in Lambeth,London.
As far as my knowledge goes it was not staged by the Ruskies as propaganda but taken by a fellow Soldier at an execution!
I see no reason why the SS photo would not be originally in the RAD album also,the Rad album in itself is very nice!

Ross

[štajerc]

2

here I make 2 more photos - paper is exactly the same as on rad photos agfa lupex... and you can see it is not print..