Big Question: UV light positive = Fake photos ?

[ERIC LIN]

Hi Guys
I just bought a set of Hitler's Nürnberg Rally from E-stand 2 mouths ago. I am doubt their authenticity, once I got my first UV light yesterday.

I have read the Robert website about the UV test
http://www.kriegsberichter.de/Data/fake10e.htm

Sadly the set of Hitler's Nürnberg Rally photos are UV light positive....please see my photos below!!!

So, my question is:
DO THE UV LIGHT IS THE DIRECT WAY TO DETECT THE FAKE PHOTOS?

If this set of photo goes wrong, I will like to make a refund from that guy who said they are Original.

[ERIC LIN]

I blocked a original photo in the middle to compare the light.
it looks brighter of the Rally photo

Many of the buyers were also bought from him, if things goes wrong, I hope the guy could pay his honest.....





Thanks
Eric

[ERIC LIN]

Anyone? any expert?


Eric

[edison10728]

Guys~ please help!

[John Pen.]

Nothing against the seller here(perhaps he was unaware).
But those pics appear to be NOT period prints.

Jp

p.s., I'm not an "expert" , this is my opinion based on what I see.
Besides, generally speaking, bright glowing photos always equals post-war paper/printing, probably never an exception to this rule.

[HouweTrouwe]

Chemicals in the new (postwar) paint glows under UV..

[John Pen.]

"paint" = emulsion.

Jp
...also more recently, the paper itself.

[imi]

maybe the better quality lightning under UV

[Andrew Harris]

maybe the better quality lightning under UV

What do you mean?

[germanww2photos]

Looks like what you bought were modern copies of the Adolf Hitler Sammelbilder series photo cards. The original collector photos were mass produced but I see alot of them copied and offered as original private photos which is false.
The original series photos have printed captions on back with the series number. Nothing rare about them, but some are very nice.
Does the seller offer your money back?

[ERIC LIN]

Thanks of you guys

Sure! The seller offer me full money refund. He is a good man

Eric

[edison10728]

[John Pen.]