My collection of signature original

[max history]

HELLO
I AM ONE CAN LOST IN ANY CA AND I DO NOT KNOW RAINED TOO MUCH WHAT TO MAKE
BE YOU A COLLECTOR OR A PROFESSIONEL?
WHICH INDICATION ALLOWS YOU TO DEDUCT THAT SIGNATURES ARE FALSE
THESE TWO PHOTOS I BOUGHT THEM FROM MILITARIARELICS
HE POSEDE ANOTHER HITLER'S PHOTO
OF WHAT THINK OF IT YOU?

I'm not sure what you mean here. The bottom line is that it's a matter of opinion and you have asked for opinions. frankandfrank first pointed out that the Hitler photo, the Göring photo and the Goebbels photo were fake in his opinion. In my opinion, I agree with him. Jon-Olav Holden also agrees they are fake. We are experienced autograph collectors, not professionals.
On the other hand, you believe the Hitler and Goebbels to be authentic and you have COAs in support. In addition, the seller also believes them to be authentic.
I mentioned that I am not a believer in COAs, but many people swear by them. Again, it's a matter of choice. However, if I wanted a signature authenticated I would take it to a specialist autograph authenticator, not a general militaria dealer. In saying that, I am sure militaria dealers are experts in their own field and I would not question their authentication of an item of militaria as I do not not have the expertise.
Remember, everyone can make mistakes, including dealers and no matter how experienced a collector. As collectors we can only give our opinions and if you are happy with the signatures, then that's all that matters.
Good hunting!
Max.

[Jon. H]

I'm not sure what you mean here. The bottom line is that it's a matter of opinion and you have asked for opinions. frankandfrank first pointed out that the Hitler photo, the Göring photo and the Goebbels photo were fake in his opinion. In my opinion, I agree with him. Jon-Olav Holden also agrees they are fake. We are experienced autograph collectors, not professionals.
On the other hand, you believe the Hitler and Goebbels to be authentic and you have COAs in support. In addition, the seller also believes them to be authentic.
I mentioned that I am not a believer in COAs, but many people swear by them. Again, it's a matter of choice. However, if I wanted a signature authenticated I would take it to a specialist autograph authenticator, not a general militaria dealer. In saying that, I am sure militaria dealers are experts in their own field and I would not question their authentication of an item of militaria as I do not not have the expertise.
Remember, everyone can make mistakes, including dealers and no matter how experienced a collector. As collectors we can only give our opinions and if you are happy with the signatures, then that's all that matters.
Good hunting!
Max.

Dealers are dealers. Many know's what they are doing, some doesn't, and some does but still offer crap (not pointing to any dealer!).

As Max said, they can't know everything. And signatures is a field where dealers often are mistaken, specially on signed photos.

[christof]

Dear DLD13,

A little advice, these guys know what they say ! IMHO (I'm not collecting signature) you should beleve them more than any dealer... Dealers make money and WAF member are trying to help you to save some money ! If you want a good test to know if your Hitler's signature is good or not, try to sale it cheap to a serious collector. If he say no, I dont want it, you will be sure that it's a fake !

[frankandfrank]

HELLO
I AM ONE CAN LOST IN ANY CA AND I DO NOT KNOW RAINED TOO MUCH WHAT TO MAKE
BE YOU A COLLECTOR OR A PROFESSIONEL?
WHICH INDICATION ALLOWS YOU TO DEDUCT THAT SIGNATURES ARE FALSE
THESE TWO PHOTOS I BOUGHT THEM FROM MILITARIARELICS
HE POSEDE ANOTHER HITLER'S PHOTO
OF WHAT THINK OF IT YOU?
http://www.militariarelics.com/Default.aspx?C=x

The most of the wartime signature are dirty very cheap postwar fakes !
Nothing do to with original signatures !

There are so cheap faked, that i can only laugh !