authentic or not?

[Bob K]

What do you think?
#1





#2





#3

[Spitfire]

Hi Bob

pic #1 tinnie looks ok, not sure about the HSF badge

pic #2 from what I can see of the picture, both CABs look ok

pic #3 Destroyer not good, Aux Cruiser not keen on this, best to wait for replys from others.

Al

[Darrell]

Can't comment on the tinnie, but nothing else is good.

[Stu W]

I don't think any of the KM badges are good. I can't speak to the tinnie.

Regards,
Stu

[John R.]

Please post each item in a separate thread and use much larger and clearer images for discussion.

John

[BubbaZ]

One of the CABs and AC have a chance to be good Rettenmeiers but better images are required to confirm or deny that. Rest is crap. I do not know anything about the tinnie.
Cheers,
Hubert

[John R.]

Bob wants to keep it open.

[Stepdale]

Bob,
Just like you decided with the Heer badges from this auction, you shouldn't take the risk to bid on these without getting better photos to post here. If experts like John and Hubert can't be sure from these pictures, I certainly wouldn't risk it.
Dale

[Bob K]

I've been under the weather the last couple of days, but if I can get out Friday afternoon, I'll try to get some better photos. If I do, I'll post them Friday evening.

[Martin W]

Better photo's would really help to be able to give a more positive opinion here Bob,especially with my old eyes.

If you can,try to photograph the badges individually and then post them.

Cheers,Martin.

[ValhallaMilitaria]

The tinnie is fine, these are so common that I doubt that anyone is faking them, I have 2-3 in my resell tray right now.
Eric