Opinions on this hollow back U-Boat

[Andy B.]

Hi Guys,
Well since everyone cleared up the IAB for me, I thought I might throw this one out there for opinions. The only history I know on it was that it was purchased in an antique shop in Illinois in the '60's. I have my doubts about it, so no one is going to hurt my feelings, so please be honest.
Andy B. collecting mini badge stickpins

[Andy B.]

here is the back

[Andy B.]

angle shot showing the hinge and catch. sorry I can't get closer.

[Philippe DB]

Hi Andy,


Hollow KM badges are generaly unacceptable. As an exception to that rule there seems to be one hollow U-boat badge ( the one with the vertical set-up on top of the badge) where the jury is still undecided but that's it.

In relation to the badge you posted and although I like the finish, I don't think that this is an original. For me the typical '57 catch, never used on war time pieces, is the biggest give away.

KR
Philippe

[Andy B.]

Thanks Phillipe, It was as I suspected . I guess it will be a decent filler till I can get a good one. Christmas is coming, maybe Ms. Claus will suprise me in my stocking .

Andy B. collecting mini badge stickpins.

[mrg]

Hi Hab, Im not to keen on these hollow backed U-boat badges and like Philippe said the jurys still somewhat split.I myself would much prefer a positive yes than a maybe. After all you never know if you might want to sell or even upgrade later and these dont appeal to everyone. Just my thought. All the best