Help would be appreciated, badges real or fake?

[Waffenampt280]

Hello all!

Just wanted some expert opinions on these three badges.
Real or fake?

Thanks!

[JAndrew]

My opinions:
CAB may be good but the reverse photo is so dark it is hard for me to tell. The reverse pitting is worrisome to me but not unheard of on some old zincers.
HSF looks like a post war Souval piece to me based, among other things, on the catch.
I really don't like the destroyer badge at all.
I would pass on all of these.
Sorry.
JAndrew

[Norm F]

My opinions:
CAB may be good but the reverse photo is so dark it is hard for me to tell. The reverse pitting is worrisome to me but not unheard of on some old zincers.
HSF looks like a post war Souval piece to me based, among other things, on the catch.
I really don't like the destroyer badge at all.
I would pass on all of these.
Sorry.
JAndrew

I agree completely with this assessment.

Best regards,
---Norm

[BubbaZ]

I would pass on all of these.

This is also what I would do!
Even if the RS CAB is ok, which I seriously doubt, it has almost no value in such condition.
Cheers,
Hubert

[maestro]

[petopoint]

yurp

Yup, That Hsf has a rudie suvoul mark I haven't come across yet.
Could it be a copy of a copy of a real suoval?



Peto at point

[Waffenampt280]

Thank you all for your feedback!
You all saved me much $$$!

Best wishes!