Three Navy Badges for review

[ShedHunter]

Here are three navy badges that I am going to put on the e-stand if they check out OK. Any help on makers for the two unmarked and authenticity for the three would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks everyone!!
Tony

[ShedHunter]

pics

more

[ShedHunter]

pics

and finally..

[Norm F]

Hi Tony,

1) A good tombak Destroyer, the so-called "unmarked G.W.L", which was made by either the firm of Gebrüder Wegerhoff, Lüdenscheid or by Wilhelm Deumer (we can't be sure which but either way in Lüdenscheid).

2) Unfortunately a high end reproduction of a Schwerin Fleet badge.

3) A good tombak U-boat of the Schickle/Mayer design, heavily hand vaulted, but we'd need to see closeups of the catch in profile to determine if it's been replaced or not.

Best regards,
---Norm

[ShedHunter]

Catch pics

Thank You Norm! Wow another fake. Does not suprise me anymore.
Here are a couple more pics of the Sub badge catch.
Thanks again,
Tony

[Norm F]

Hi Tony,

The catch on the U-boat is good and original. That type of round wire catch with the flattened base is less common on these U-boats and is more typical of the Schickle/Mayer-type Destroyer badges. Nice to see.

Best regards,
---Norm

[ShedHunter]

Thank You very much Norm. The knowledge on this forum is truly unreal. Its good to know there was a dud in the mix before I put it on the e-stand.
Thanks again!!
Tony

[BubbaZ]

Hi Tony,

1) A good tombak Destroyer, the so-called "unmarked G.W.L", which was made by either the firm of Gebrüder Wegerhoff, Lüdenscheid or by Wilhelm Deumer (we can't be sure which but either way in Lüdenscheid).

2) Unfortunately a high end reproduction of a Schwerin Fleet badge.

3) A good tombak U-boat of the Schickle/Mayer design, heavily hand vaulted

Hi Tony,
I fully agree with Norm's assesment.
Cheers,
Hubert

[ShedHunter]

Thanks again. I will put the two good ones on the e-stand later today.
Tony