Honour Roll Clasp

[STEVIEBOY491]

Hi there,

I have had the offer of this naval honour roll claso and having never owned one before would very much like your opinions.

Regards

Steve

[STEVIEBOY491]

1

[STEVIEBOY491]

3

[STEVIEBOY491]

4

[STEVIEBOY491]

5

[STEVIEBOY491]

6

[STEVIEBOY491]

7

[Patrick W]

Hi Steve

Not convinced on that one, we need to see closeups of the prongs and how they are attached to the clasp, they should have small serations at the angle and have a tiny round plate where they are soldered on. Also the prongs look a little long on this one

[STEVIEBOY491]

Patrick,

I will see what I can do. Many thanks for your input so far.

Regards

Steve

[Thomas E Hansen]

Patrick,

I will see what I can do. Many thanks for your input so far.

Regards

Steve

Hey there.
Personally I would let i go...

Because..
The anchor is quite misschapen
The prongs on the rear looks like they got a needle tip and they are also missing the """""" on the needle, sorry I dont know the name of them.
There are no "dots" under the anchor.

Maybe its a good one but I would find another one.

Regards Thomas.


http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/serv...rine_clasp.htm

[rhudspith]

Hey there.
Personally I would let i go...

Because..
The anchor is quite misschapen
The prongs on the rear looks like they got a needle tip and they are also missing the """""" on the needle, sorry I dont know the name of them.
There are no "dots" under the anchor.

Maybe its a good one but I would find another one.

Regards Thomas.


http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/serv...rine_clasp.htm

Agree with Thomas, looks a good effort, but IMO not original, does not exhibit the features I would expect to be present, so would not be for me. Perhaps some more of these may come out of the woodwork in the future, one to watch out for.

For info I would class the one shown below as original Check out the design of the anchor "arrowheads"

Out of interest how much is it being offered to you, is it from a private collector or dealer?

[Thomas E Hansen]

Agree with Thomas, looks a good effort, but IMO not original, does not exhibit the features I would expect to be present, so would not be for me. Perhaps some more of these may come out of the woodwork in the future, one to watch out for.

For info I would class the one shown below as original Check out the design of the anchor "arrowheads"

Out of interest how much is it being offered to you, is it from a private collector or dealer?

Nice original piece you got there.

[John R.]

Red= shear marks

Blue= fluke (s)

[STEVIEBOY491]

Thanks for all of your help.

I will let it pass I think. It was beingh offered from a dealer for 1200 euros.

Regards

Steve

[Steve P]

Red= shear marks

Blue= fluke (s)

Sorry John, I don't know these well at all...what are you pointing out above?